Comments | cladinthedark: 24th Crystal: [Voice]

cladinthedark

24th Crystal: [Voice]

Nov 22, 2009 02:14

Before you make a decision on the offer, consider carefully just what they've written ( Read more... )

there's something fishy here, untrustworthy, a flaw in their logic

Comments 96

(The comment has been removed)

cladinthedark November 22 2009, 17:44:48 UTC

Well, it would seem there's at least one blatant lie in it.

(The comment has been removed)

cladinthedark November 23 2009, 03:12:57 UTC

To be honest, no. But I can't prove it isn't.

Thread 8

vulcanblazer November 22 2009, 08:25:09 UTC

Yeah, it is. I saved my world from its threat, and it was peaceful when I was taken. ...And time's supposed to stand still for your home while you're here, isn't it?

cladinthedark November 22 2009, 17:45:45 UTC

That last point is what I was referring to. How can our presence be missed if events, including the ones we are involved in, seem to have gone the same way?

vulcanblazer November 22 2009, 18:33:53 UTC

That's a good point too... I didn't think about that, considering I think I'm from the furthest in the future of anyone I know here. So if things back home happen the way they're supposed to, despite us being trapped...

...Yeah, this is whole thing is a grade-A crock of bullshit.

cladinthedark November 23 2009, 03:13:41 UTC

That would be the logical conclusion. [If not how he would have phrased it.]

[voice] blue_velocity November 22 2009, 08:25:21 UTC

Exactly. S'why I'm not buyin' it.

[voice] cladinthedark November 22 2009, 17:47:25 UTC

Precisely my thoughts on the matter.

[voice] blue_velocity November 22 2009, 18:21:59 UTC

Yeah, the whole future gettin' messed up thing is what got me. We're all from different points in time, and nothin' changed back home just cuz some of us are here.

[voice] cladinthedark November 23 2009, 03:14:30 UTC

That's what convinced me as well. I didn't trust it even before I noticed that detail, but it was the final straw.

Thread 12

[Written] dragoon_pride November 22 2009, 09:16:01 UTC

That may well be... but it doesn't change my own decision.

[Written] cladinthedark November 22 2009, 17:48:24 UTC

I wouldn't dream of trying to convince you otherwise, Kain.

[Largely because he knows that his placement on one side of an argument will probably have Kain move to the other side just out of principle.]

[Written] dragoon_pride November 22 2009, 19:15:07 UTC

[Basically... yes. This is true.]

I have nothing to lose by attempting it.

[Written] cladinthedark November 23 2009, 03:15:30 UTC

One wonders...

[And he's just going to leave it at that.]

rubyeyes_ryuhou November 22 2009, 10:06:18 UTC

Yes, I do find it strange. Someone who recently arrived from my world had no idea that I was gone for over a year and a half. He said he'd seen me six months ago.

cladinthedark November 22 2009, 17:49:19 UTC

And you're not the only one with experiences like that. That gives us a direct contradiction with what they've said.

rubyeyes_ryuhou November 23 2009, 04:11:20 UTC

Which makes me only more certain that this is either a trap or another experiment.

cladinthedark November 23 2009, 18:08:30 UTC

I lean towards the latter.