Challenge #7 - Round #7 - Chicago - Results

Aug 26, 2008 14:25

I'm really sorry, but we have to say good bye to this following participants



Eliminated:

by angrymobjustice with 3 votes

People's choice:

by selenespain with 2 votes


by ksi_liv with 2 votes

Voting Tally
If your icon number is not listed here, then it means that you have received no votes! Congratulations!

1. +2
2. -3+2= -1
3. -5+2= -3
4. -1+3= +2

- = lesser quality vote(s)
+ = favorite icon vote(s)

Trivia
- 4/5 participants entered round #7
- 2 reminders + extention
- 9 people voted
- 1 elimination + 2 people's choice

Eliminate:
2: The text is unreadable, the icon seems oversharpened, the trees are unnaturally violet.
002. the coloring is really strange and it just doesn't work well. the text is too bunched together
2 - croping don't give any pluses to icon, too many light textures, text doesn't fit

3: too dark because of the texture, which is overpowering
#3 - this heart textures doesn't match the icon
#03 - grayscale is boring; there's nothing to really draw the attention
#3: The texture is not complimenting the image, its too 'dusty' too and the colors are unbalanced, and off.
003 - The texture leads into nothing. Focal point is off. Whole icon is a bit wishy-washy.

#4 - Placement of text seems off; makes the icon look unbalanced. Color texture clashes with the picture.

To keep:
#1 - text and coloring are great
1 - Very simple and soft; love the font.

02 - colouring is magical, effects are well-used, and it fits a mood
#2: This is what I like the best from the bunch, I like the harmony between the tetxures, the image and the text.

003. GOREGOUS icon. the idea is really great and pretty.
3: The icon may be a bit blurry, but it's creative and original, it reminds me of a postcard. Lovely.

4: lovely coloring and text
4 - great textures use and the text fits nicely too
004 - good crop. text well placed. good use of texture.

Good luck to everyone in the final round :)

challenge #7 - round #7, results

Previous post Next post
Up