Leave a comment

stabbim October 16 2007, 07:38:20 UTC
Beautiful work! It's a vid that I can watch over and over again. It's pretty and emotional and captures John's journey perfectly. Love it! I'll definitely rec your vid to my friends.

Reply

charmax October 16 2007, 12:18:18 UTC
Hiya, stabbim. Yes! Rec away, tell everyone. :D I'm so pleased you feel it's worthy of repeat viewings.

Reply

stabbim October 16 2007, 12:37:18 UTC
Your vid really impressed me. You see, I'm not exactly the biggest fan of John Winchester. I get that John raised his kids the best he could under the circumstances, but he made a lot of mistakes in the process, so I'm not too keen on seeing him celebrated as a "great" father because he wasn't, IMHO. Dean was more of a father to Sam than John was. And Dean never really felt like he had a father or he woudn't be so desperate for his dad's approval ( ... )

Reply

charmax October 16 2007, 13:13:27 UTC
Yeah, I don't feel the vid celebrates John as such. I do love him but I think his flaws are very much present in the vid. That single-minded determination has consequences for everyone. I think he loved his sons but I also think that he was so destroyed in the moment that he lost his wife that he could never quite get past that as a father. I hope some of that is visible in the vid.

I have no real plans for further SPN vids in the near future. But you never know when inspiration will strike.

Reply

stabbim October 16 2007, 13:18:02 UTC
I agree witj your assessment of John.

I hope some of that is visible in the vid.

Definitely! That's one reason why I love it so much.

I have no real plans for further SPN vids in the near future. But you never know when inspiration will strike.

No worries, I just had to ask. I'll look forward to your next vid, whatever it may be. :D

Reply


Leave a comment

Up