daf bit: Menachot 57

May 05, 2011 09:07

The g'mara on today's daf discusses the prohibition of cooking on Shabbat. If a man placed meat on the coals on Shabbat and it was roasted, he is liable. How much has to be cooked? After discussion about whether it has to be cooked through or only on one side to count, Raba said that if it was roasted in one spot the size of a dried fig that is sufficient. There is further discussion in which either Raba or Rabina said that if it is roasted in two or three spots that together add up to the size of a dried fig, that too is a violation -- it doesn't have to be a single area. Rabina then compares this to boring a hole on Shabbat, which is prohibited regardless of the size of the hole, but the difference in these cases is not addressed here. (57a)
I had assumed that any amount of cooking would be prohibited. Of course, this might not be the last word on the subject.

shabbat, daf bits

Previous post Next post
Up