Nov 12, 2005 04:07
Intelligent Design trial is over
From issue 2525 of New Scientist magazine, 12 November 2005, page 6
IT WILL be a verdict of truly biblical proportions. For 40 days Judge John Jones presided over the intelligent design trial in Pennsylvania and now he aims to decide by 1 January whether teaching ID in US science classes alongside evolution violates the constitutional ban on religious indoctrination in schools.
Eleven parents brought the case last June after objecting to the Dover High School Board's decision compelling pupils to learn about ID, the theory that the complexity of life is best explained by an unidentified supernatural creator. Lawyers for the parents sought to prove that ID is a thinly veiled attempt to repackage biblical creationism as a scientific theory, so if taught would violate the American constitution (see New Scientist, 29 October, p 6).
"We proved two key points," said Steve Harvey, an attorney for the parents. "First, that the board of education had a specifically religious purpose in enacting its policy, and second, that ID is not a scientific theory or science at all. It's a religious concept."
Harvey told New Scientist that if the judge finds for the parents, the verdict would set a precedent undermining the case for teaching ID in schools elsewhere in the US.
On a lighter note, the defendants' attorney noted that the final day was the fortieth, and asked the judge whether this was deliberate. The court collapsed in laughter when the judge replied: "Not by design".
Chat Log:
- PT : Sleeping - ORDEAL OVER! | Angeeeee ;p says:
I'm back!
- PT : Insomaniac | Angeeeee ;p says:
oiiiiii
カスパ(Kasupa) FREEDOM! (ROFLMAO@UTS and UNSW ) says:
?
- PT : Insomaniac | Angeeeee ;p says:
I said HELOOOOOOOO!
カスパ(Kasupa) FREEDOM! (ROFLMAO@UTS and UNSW ) says:
omg hi2u
カスパ(Kasupa) FREEDOM! (ROFLMAO@UTS and UNSW ) says:
asl
- PT : Insomaniac | Angeeeee ;p says:
:O :O
カスパ(Kasupa) FREEDOM! (ROFLMAO@UTS and UNSW ) says:
presss 1111 to syber
- PT : Insomaniac | Angeeeee ;p says:
11/f/florida
- PT : Insomaniac | Angeeeee ;p says:
11111111111111111
カスパ(Kasupa) FREEDOM! (ROFLMAO@UTS and UNSW ) says:
hahahahaha
カスパ(Kasupa) FREEDOM! (ROFLMAO@UTS and UNSW ) says:
you win :P
- PT : Insomaniac | Angeeeee ;p says:
syba me quicvk!!11 :'(
- PT : Insomaniac | Angeeeee ;p says:
lol
カスパ(Kasupa) FREEDOM! (ROFLMAO@UTS and UNSW ) says:
I put on my robe and wizards hat
- PT : Insomaniac | Angeeeee ;p says:
LOL
- PT : Insomaniac | Angeeeee ;p says:
ok, YOU win