But You Didn't (On Crack Part 1.)
Do you remember when we were young, and I pushed you in the lake? I thought you'd push me back. But you didn't.
Do you remember during archery practice, how I almost hit you? I thought you'd yell at me. But you didn't.
Do you remember when we were walking to Rivendell, and you said it would rain, and it did? I thought you'd say "I told you so". But you didn't.
Do you remember at the council, how I let your name slip? I thought you'd me. But you didn't.
Do you remember in Moria, when the Balrog came? I was frightened, and you knew it. I thought you'd laugh at me. But you didn't.
Do you remember when the Fellowship broke, how lost I seemed? I thought you'd tell me to leave. But you didn't.
Do you remember when I threatened that horse lord with an arrow? I thought you would get angry at me. But you didn't.
Do you remember when you came back (seemingly from ) how I hugged you, and wouldn't let you go, for fear of losing my best friend? I thought you'd shove me away. But you didn't.
Do you remeber how I doubted any would survive Helm's Deep? I thought you'd find it impossible to forgive me. But you didn't.
You've always been my best friend. You protected me, listened to me, and been there for me.
There was so much I wanted to thank you for, when you returned from Helm's Deep.
But you didn't.
Do you remember during archery practice, how I almost hit you? I thought you'd yell at me. But you didn't.
Do you remember when we were walking to Rivendell, and you said it would rain, and it did? I thought you'd say "I told you so". But you didn't.
Do you remember at the council, how I let your name slip? I thought you'd me. But you didn't.
Do you remember in Moria, when the Balrog came? I was frightened, and you knew it. I thought you'd laugh at me. But you didn't.
Do you remember when the Fellowship broke, how lost I seemed? I thought you'd tell me to leave. But you didn't.
Do you remember when I threatened that horse lord with an arrow? I thought you would get angry at me. But you didn't.
Do you remember when you came back (seemingly from ) how I hugged you, and wouldn't let you go, for fear of losing my best friend? I thought you'd shove me away. But you didn't.
Do you remeber how I doubted any would survive Helm's Deep? I thought you'd find it impossible to forgive me. But you didn't.
You've always been my best friend. You protected me, listened to me, and been there for me.
There was so much I wanted to thank you for, when you returned from Helm's Deep.
But you didn't.