Comments | campfuckuvote: (без темы)

recurrence in campfuckuvote

(Untitled)

Nov 03, 2006 16:56

Righto, time for the usual early batch. By popular demand! Box woman is going to follow this up with another batch later on. As always, apps will be open until 6 AM EST. There's still plenty of time to write and submit one ( Read more... )

Comments 162

on_target November 4 2006, 00:57:58 UTC

TEDDY TEDDY HOLY SHIT

I should read the app, huh.

OKAY ACTUAL VOTES on_target November 4 2006, 01:06:12 UTC

Teddy, IN, Alice, IN (the Russian joke did it), Kouji OUT, Ojiue IN, Kasukabe and Guy OUT. Ask here if you want details.

Kouji apper on_target November 4 2006, 01:14:13 UTC

If you're not too busy, crit would be great!

Re: Kouji apper on_target November 4 2006, 03:31:19 UTC

Check your spelling better next time, and turn up the snooty. (The "americans" in small type won.) I...liked it but it wasn't quite there for me, and I'm sorry I can't give anything more clear than that.

Thread 8

overacting November 4 2006, 01:06:53 UTC

Okay,
Teddy out.
Alice in.
Kouji out.
Ogiue out.
Abstian on Saki, since I'm undecided.
Guy in.

Questions, comments concerns?

Teddy overacting November 4 2006, 01:11:34 UTC

Might I ask why the out-vote? Crit would be much appreciated.

Re: Teddy overacting November 4 2006, 01:13:26 UTC

Teddy, really strong beginning. I totally loved the camouflaging as a zombie bit you had. But the app (for me anyway) sort of fell flat afterwards; it felt just a little disjointed, with just a lot of random thoughts thrown in together.

But good luck anyway.

Re: Teddy overacting November 4 2006, 01:16:51 UTC

Thank you for the crit.

Thread 9

dosetsu November 4 2006, 01:07:46 UTC

H-Holy scumbags Genshiken apps awesome

All right actually reading stuff now 8Db

dosetsu November 4 2006, 01:18:29 UTC

Out for Teddy and Kouji; in for everyone else!

Kouji dosetsu November 4 2006, 01:20:55 UTC

If you have the time, could I ask for some crit please?

Re: Kouji dosetsu November 4 2006, 07:44:00 UTC

Sure thing! The main thing, unfortunately, was pretty much the same issue I mentioned below with Teddy's app--this app just didn't get any solid laughs from me. I hate to just leave it at that, but it's a subjective thing and I'm honestly not sure how to crit for it in detail.

Thread 6

veryshocking November 4 2006, 01:09:25 UTC

Y'know? I was having a pretty sucky day over all, but these apps all made me giggle outloud at least once. That's enough of a reason for me to give everything an IN.

soujirire November 4 2006, 01:09:50 UTC

All in, 'cause I'm easy tonight 8D; I didn't know any of the canons, though.