I heard this song a while back and went to find a version on YouTube that jived with me more than the solo performer. I forgot to paste the video here and naturally I can't find it again.
Anyhow, It Is Well With My Soul sounds best performed by a choir, IMHO, and there isn't a shortage on YouTube. The hymn was was composed by Philip Paul Bliss with lyrics by Horatio G. Spafford in 1876.
Click to view