Leave a comment

Comments 9

juushika May 25 2009, 22:09:03 UTC
Interesting, very interesting. The concept catches my attention but based on your review and others on Amazon, I'm wary of the way execution. I think this is a book to add to my library queue, where I can try it without investing money. Thanks for you review. ^^

Reply

calico_reaction May 25 2009, 22:22:25 UTC
That's an excellent plan. I look forward to hearing your thoughts, so be sure to let me know when you've read it!

Reply


chicklitter May 26 2009, 00:20:34 UTC
Okay, I'm confused just reading that.

As for the cover, it is a very striking image.

Reply

calico_reaction May 26 2009, 00:30:31 UTC
Oh dear, I hope the review isn't confusing. :)

Reply

chicklitter May 26 2009, 00:43:09 UTC
No, it's more that the story itself sounds confusing.

Reply

calico_reaction May 26 2009, 00:47:01 UTC
Yeah, I read it twice. :)

Reply


ext_313750 November 8 2010, 11:07:06 UTC
I really like your review, your thoughts about this book are almost exactly what mine were. I too was frustrated by not knowing more about ancient Greek philosophers, I kept worrying that I was missing out on some extra parallels with history. But you're right, there are no real links between Anax in the book and the Anaxaminder in history - I think the point was just supposed to be that these people are all radical thinkers ( ... )

Reply

calico_reaction November 8 2010, 17:34:00 UTC
But we never really saw any progress, did we, in terms of Anax's fate? That's why it was so easy for me to boil down the message to "thinking outside the box = bad." :)

Thanks for commenting!

Reply

ext_313750 November 9 2010, 04:22:47 UTC
No, because her society eliminates radical thinkers before they can cause any progress. But Adam kills Joseph to save Eve and in doing so saves his society from the Republic, then Art kills Adam to propagate a new society for his kind.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up