The Big Time Reality Question (a.k.a. Jen needs sleep!)

[lizwinlove]

So, my crappy insomnia had me watching BTR at 6:30 in the morning on a Saturday. Ewww. I have all the episodes on my DVR, so it's not like I would have missed anything if I'd been asleep! But at any rate, today's BTR was Big Time Reality. Sometime during the course of the episode, Griffin decides at the end of the reality show season one member of

Comments

[phantompearl]

(tl;dr): If I were a viewer of that reality show in the showverse, and I had to vote off one (not that I ever really vote in reality shows), I think it all depends on how well I knew each of them from press junkets and how I liked their music and each of their singing ability. Them being interviewed/etc. happens seemingly rare when we watch the Nick show so how well would I know and feel for those boys? I love the boys so much and know so much about them and if it were any other group of some sort then I wouldn't care as much. I would've thought if I had to I'd vote off Logan or Carlos, but even James might not be safe with me. But I really wouldn't want to vote off anybody, it was a really stupid wrench thrown in, fans shouldn't have to vote off a band member unless there's something serious going on where one may need to be dismissed.(/tl;dr)

Logan Mitchell, maybe I wouldn't want to get rid of him because of his smartness as I like that in a person in real life as Mitchell would be a part of my reality (but I'm less sympathetic to those kinds of made up characters), but maybe I wouldn't have liked the non-stop kissing/romance and awful flirting on the reality show, depends on how much that would be a deterrence for me, and what if I thought he was the weakest singer. Carlos Garcia, I don't know, maybe I wouldn't want to get rid of him because he would be too sweet to kick out, but on the reality show I would not like the non-stop fighting at all (I wouldn't know for sure it was all an act, though considering their friendships and the fact it's a reality show maybe I could've thought it was an act). James Diamond, also with the non-stop fighting and plus the punching people would be a major turn-off for me if there was any truth to it, but it depends on what else I knew about him. Would I have picked up on all the pride, determination, talent, heart, humorous, etc. that I actually like about him (I especially like those in made-up characters), along with keeping the thought of how much I love how well he can sing (probably my deciding factor) and how good he looks XD? Or would I be like my real life self where I don't like arrogant douche players etc. and would believe he was one? Kendall Knight would be safe by me I wouldn't really have any problems with him and, as much as I'd want to know more about the boys even in a reality show format, I liked that he didn't really want to do it and the show looked godawful anyway, I don't know how much I would've lasted watching it, especially if it would've turned out to be the same thing all the time. As for how other viewers would have voted, I don't know, as I said I don't know how much they know about them, maybe it would be Logan I don't know.

In real life, wow, I can't just like three of them together (same with showverse of course), and I love James interacting and singing with them so I would withhold voting him out just to fall back on a solo career, so he's safe by me no matter what. If I had to, maybe Logan would be who I'd vote off due to a slightly weaker ability and maybe I would want to have peeks at his personality the least, but I don't think anything calls for a need to get rid of any of them at all

Wow ok I seriously need to stop and shut up.