challenge 09; round 03: results
Thank you to everyone who participated and voted this round. Keep up the good work! Unfortunately one person must go this round...
ELIMINATED \\ dudette-in-town
with -4 votes
ELIMINATED \\ exotic-xia
with -4 votes
Sorry to see you go, but I hope you stick around to vote and come back for the next challenge!
VOTER'S CHOICE \\ redhour
with +4 votes
(thank you!)
MOD'S CHOICE \\ x-sweetsurprise
BANNER
TALLY:
If your number is not listed, you received no comments.
01: - - - - | -4 | ELIMINATED
03: + | +1 | MOD'S CHOICE
04: + + + + | +4 | VOTER'S CHOICE
05: + + + | +3 |
06: - - - - | -4 | ELIMINATED
COMMENTS:
01.
by dudette-in-town
- The coloring should have been done differently, so its not SO yellow/green. I understand its the lighting of the image, but with more blue tones, it would have looked a little better.
- There is too much going on in this icon! The coloring isn't flattering (she almost looks like a zombie), there are too many textures/stripe-y things, and the text is hard to read because it doesn't really pop. I do like the lighting though!
- The composition looks out of proportion. The text placement and the cropping of the image do not work well together. Maybe it would've helped if the text would've been smaller. And also, the coloring is a little too green on her hair, which is not flattering.
- The coloring is too bright, the font choice doesn't work well with the overall icon neither does the color choice for the font.
02.
by fuuurs
NO VOTES
03.
by x-sweetsurprise
+ This icon's simplicity is really eye-catching. I loved the subtle b&w coloring and the text. Both font and placement are great.
04.
by redhour
+ Great colouring and text placement.
+ The simplicity works very well, and this icon did the best job with the text!
+ the image is nicely sharpened and colored. and i like the shadowing effect behind the figure. the lyrics go well with the pic being used and the coloring of the font goes well too
+ really nice text decoration and the negative space around the image works nicely.
05.
by jorge-2
+ The crop of this image was done well, the coloring is amazing, everything just fits so perfectly together, even the lyrics compared to the image.
+ A perfect combination of image, colouring, placement, and text use
+ The coloring and cropping is amazing, there's a good balance, the text and font choice work really well with the icon too.
06.
by exotic-xia
- The text is difficult to see.
- The text placement is slightly awkward and I feel that the use of the glow makes the text a little difficult to read in places
- the effect used on the font makes it look blurry and the last word can be hard to read because of the tree in the background. and the lyrics used doesn't really fit with the image being used
- the text does not blend in well with the text. it might have looked better if it wasn't placed on the tree.
Did I miscount the votes? Does a comment not make sense? Think a comment needs to be fixed? Let me know about any of those things, or even anything at all about the entire round. I will do the best that I can to fix!
ELIMINATED \\ dudette-in-town
with -4 votes
ELIMINATED \\ exotic-xia
with -4 votes
Sorry to see you go, but I hope you stick around to vote and come back for the next challenge!
VOTER'S CHOICE \\ redhour
with +4 votes
(thank you!)
MOD'S CHOICE \\ x-sweetsurprise
BANNER
TALLY:
If your number is not listed, you received no comments.
01: - - - - | -4 | ELIMINATED
03: + | +1 | MOD'S CHOICE
04: + + + + | +4 | VOTER'S CHOICE
05: + + + | +3 |
06: - - - - | -4 | ELIMINATED
COMMENTS:
01.
by dudette-in-town
- The coloring should have been done differently, so its not SO yellow/green. I understand its the lighting of the image, but with more blue tones, it would have looked a little better.
- There is too much going on in this icon! The coloring isn't flattering (she almost looks like a zombie), there are too many textures/stripe-y things, and the text is hard to read because it doesn't really pop. I do like the lighting though!
- The composition looks out of proportion. The text placement and the cropping of the image do not work well together. Maybe it would've helped if the text would've been smaller. And also, the coloring is a little too green on her hair, which is not flattering.
- The coloring is too bright, the font choice doesn't work well with the overall icon neither does the color choice for the font.
02.
by fuuurs
NO VOTES
03.
by x-sweetsurprise
+ This icon's simplicity is really eye-catching. I loved the subtle b&w coloring and the text. Both font and placement are great.
04.
by redhour
+ Great colouring and text placement.
+ The simplicity works very well, and this icon did the best job with the text!
+ the image is nicely sharpened and colored. and i like the shadowing effect behind the figure. the lyrics go well with the pic being used and the coloring of the font goes well too
+ really nice text decoration and the negative space around the image works nicely.
05.
by jorge-2
+ The crop of this image was done well, the coloring is amazing, everything just fits so perfectly together, even the lyrics compared to the image.
+ A perfect combination of image, colouring, placement, and text use
+ The coloring and cropping is amazing, there's a good balance, the text and font choice work really well with the icon too.
06.
by exotic-xia
- The text is difficult to see.
- The text placement is slightly awkward and I feel that the use of the glow makes the text a little difficult to read in places
- the effect used on the font makes it look blurry and the last word can be hard to read because of the tree in the background. and the lyrics used doesn't really fit with the image being used
- the text does not blend in well with the text. it might have looked better if it wasn't placed on the tree.
Did I miscount the votes? Does a comment not make sense? Think a comment needs to be fixed? Let me know about any of those things, or even anything at all about the entire round. I will do the best that I can to fix!