challenge 6; round 1: results

[redhour]

Unfortunately we must say bye to the following this week:

by jane948 with -4 votes.
Thanks for participating, hope you stay around!

VOTER'S CHOICE:

by rockn-rose with +3 votes and


by nopamuk with +3 votes

MOD'S CHOICE:

by dance-the-dance
I love the brightness of it, it really stands out, and the text/font is a great addition to the icon

TALLY
2; + - = 0
3; + - = 0
6; + + + = +3 >> VOTER'S CHOICE
9; + - = 0
10; - - - - = -4 >> ELIMINATED
11; + + + = +3 >> VOTER'S CHOICE
12; + = +1
13; - - - = -3

COMMENTS
2:
- Skin is too orange, over saturated
+ The brightness of the coloring looks great, the font/text behind Britney fits nicely

3:
- it's dark-ish and cropping is quite plain
+ Nice coloring

6:
+ Good crop and use of textures... A little bit sharpened, though
+ Nice use of texture
+ The coloring and crop is well done; the background texture fits well

9:
- Britney is a little pixelated; the texture doesn't fit well
+ good use of texture/brush

10:
- Coloring is really pale; also, the texture/brush used makes it look sharpened
- Color is dull, slightly over sharpened
- The coloring sin' very attractive meaning Brintey's very yellow-ish
- The coloring is boring/too plain and it's a little too tan-ish

11:
+ Fantastic contrast and colors. Everything fits nicely
+ Very crisp, clean coloring
+ Good crop.

12:
+ pretty coloring

13:
- Too much blur
- her face is blurry
- The icons is very blurry

If you have any questions, feel free to ask.

jorge-2, you may post round two now :)