challenge 5; round 1: results
Unfortunately we must say by to the following this week:
by surfhus with -6 votes
Thanks for participating, hope you stay around!
VOTER'S CHOICE:
by jane948 with +3 votes
MOD'S CHOICE:
by xhilariousx
Great coloring and nice crop.
TALLY
1; + - - - - - = -4
2; + - = 0
3; + + + = +3 >> VOTER'S CHOICE
4; - - - - = -4
5; - - - = -3
8; - = -1
10; - - - - - - = -6 >> ELIMINATED
11; + - = 0
12; + = +1
COMMENTS
1:
- the effects used turned her really orange, and the crop is just slightly off
- I feel that the cropping is very awkward because it throws off the vertical balance of the icon. The text is also sitting in the white area in a very strange place. It seems uncentered to me
- There is so much border and negative space you can barely see Brit.
- Head is cut off and there's a huge blank spot at the bottom
+ Interesting crop; the font fits with the icon
2:
- The use of text is lame
+ Great color, crop and use of elements like the background graphics
3:
+ simple icon, good effects, beautiful coloring
+ The radial blur is nicely done, and the coloring is very nice
+ The coloring is nice & soft, & the swirl effect is a nice touch
4:
- the effects used are not quite right, the crop makes her face look big
- I feel that the black in the background of this is too stark against the neon pink. I think adding a lighter texture to the background would have worked better
- The texture used just really throw off the icon, and it's too heavy on one side
- The black background and pink details do not compliment the colouring of the image
5:
- too much going on with the background, the text and the stock image, doesn't all go together well
- Blah text, bad textures
- Poor image contrast
8:
- The icon seems to have a very green overlay, the skin looks really off having blended with the green color
10:
- The coloring is way too strong on this icon. Some of the image quality has been lost because of the contrasting
- The blue background has too much contrast with Brit's yellow skin. The colors do not complement each other
- Odd cropping and colors
- It's oversaturated
- Her skin is a bit too orange & unnatural
- The colouring has made her skin appear bright orange
11:
- The image looks very blurred out, the cropping is a bit awkward
+ The colouring is beautiful and unique
12:
+ Best coloring of the bunch. I adore the crop and slight disaturation. The font is an odd choice but very "now"
If you have any questions, feel free to ask.
by surfhus with -6 votes
Thanks for participating, hope you stay around!
VOTER'S CHOICE:
by jane948 with +3 votes
MOD'S CHOICE:
by xhilariousx
Great coloring and nice crop.
TALLY
1; + - - - - - = -4
2; + - = 0
3; + + + = +3 >> VOTER'S CHOICE
4; - - - - = -4
5; - - - = -3
8; - = -1
10; - - - - - - = -6 >> ELIMINATED
11; + - = 0
12; + = +1
COMMENTS
1:
- the effects used turned her really orange, and the crop is just slightly off
- I feel that the cropping is very awkward because it throws off the vertical balance of the icon. The text is also sitting in the white area in a very strange place. It seems uncentered to me
- There is so much border and negative space you can barely see Brit.
- Head is cut off and there's a huge blank spot at the bottom
+ Interesting crop; the font fits with the icon
2:
- The use of text is lame
+ Great color, crop and use of elements like the background graphics
3:
+ simple icon, good effects, beautiful coloring
+ The radial blur is nicely done, and the coloring is very nice
+ The coloring is nice & soft, & the swirl effect is a nice touch
4:
- the effects used are not quite right, the crop makes her face look big
- I feel that the black in the background of this is too stark against the neon pink. I think adding a lighter texture to the background would have worked better
- The texture used just really throw off the icon, and it's too heavy on one side
- The black background and pink details do not compliment the colouring of the image
5:
- too much going on with the background, the text and the stock image, doesn't all go together well
- Blah text, bad textures
- Poor image contrast
8:
- The icon seems to have a very green overlay, the skin looks really off having blended with the green color
10:
- The coloring is way too strong on this icon. Some of the image quality has been lost because of the contrasting
- The blue background has too much contrast with Brit's yellow skin. The colors do not complement each other
- Odd cropping and colors
- It's oversaturated
- Her skin is a bit too orange & unnatural
- The colouring has made her skin appear bright orange
11:
- The image looks very blurred out, the cropping is a bit awkward
+ The colouring is beautiful and unique
12:
+ Best coloring of the bunch. I adore the crop and slight disaturation. The font is an odd choice but very "now"
If you have any questions, feel free to ask.