Idol - Top 5
Two Hours..2- songs….lots of filler! Here we go!
Must be Bruce Springsteen night..there’s a bio. Little Steie is the mentor.
Hollie - River Deep Mountain High - Not a bad job…She’s got a great voice!!!!
Phil - The Letter - Nice arrangement! Not sure if this would have a place at radio..but he’s killing it! Nice job.
Skylar - Fortunate Son - She can work that stage…she commands it!!!!! Lovin’ this. Again..she’s my favorite!!!!!
Joshua/Phil Duet - You’ve lost that loving feelin - And another train wreck…horrible!!! Phil so out of what he’s good at..even looked uncomfortable. Joshua even bad.
Jessica - Proud Mary - Not a bad job..in the battle that is Tina Turner..I think Hollie was the winner.
Joshua - Ain’t Too Proud To Beg - Perfect song for him! Nice job. This is where he belongs…He did get a little Yawwwwwy at the end.
Hollie and Skylar win for me
Hollie - Bleeding Love - Such a nice job. Nice pick. We will be hearing a lot from her!!
Phil - Time of the Season - Wrong choice! Mess.
Hollie/Skylar/Jessica Trio - Higher and Higher - I don’t like Jessica on this. But they are better than the boys.
Skylar - You Don’t Have To Say You Love Me - You know..every year I whine and moan about the country one…this year…I want her to win!!!! How did that happen???? Awesome job! Love it!!!
Jessica - You Are So Beautiful - In control of her massive voice. Even some restraint….very nice job!
Joshua - To Love Somebody - Again with the restraint..refreshing from his growly Yawwwwws…(which as I write this..he goes to at the end) I enjoyed the early part of this….he needs to pull back the yowl a bit.
It’s a pleasure this year with the talent. Everyone seems so polished, and keep getting better.
Wow…with so few..and weird voting..anyone could go home..This is hard - weakest of the night for me was Phil..I’d put Joshua in the bottom 2 as well. Maybe Jessica as the third.