Results - Round Two - Challenge Two
I'm terribly sorry about the delay, there was a communication error.
The way Yachiru directed us to do this is put up the two icons voted out, along with the count. Then there will be a voting tally where everyone can see if his or her icon got a negative vote or a vote for favorite. If you want to see the comments received for your icon in either case, leave a comment to this post with the number of your icon. Those comments will be screened to give iconmakers privacy.
And now. The results.
BRAWL LIMS - Round Two - Challenge Two - RESULTS
Voted Off:
by kidoban with 15 votes
by flippybitch with 10 votes
We'll be very sad to see your icon-making abilities go.
Now for the Audience's Top Choice as well as the Mod's Choices.
Audience's Choice:
by masaharu_puri with 4 votes
There was a tie, so the tie breaker was the icon with the least number of negative votes.
Yumichika's Choice:
by whatsurwish
While this wasn't my first choice for mod's choice - the one I had orginally chosen recieved audience's choice - it is still a well made icon. The colors are rich and eye catching and make the subject stand out.
Kuchiki's Choice:
by eyesuphereplz
The lighting is really pretty, the text is perfect, and the cropping is really interesting. I like it! :D
The voting tally is as follows...
1. -3, +3
2. -6, +4
3. -4, +4
4. -2, +1
5. -15, +0
6. -4, +3
7. -1, +3
8. -4, +1
9. -3, +0
10. -6, +1
11. -4, +2
12. -6, +1
13. -10, +0
For those 11 still in the competition, I'll be putting up the next challenge shortly.
The way Yachiru directed us to do this is put up the two icons voted out, along with the count. Then there will be a voting tally where everyone can see if his or her icon got a negative vote or a vote for favorite. If you want to see the comments received for your icon in either case, leave a comment to this post with the number of your icon. Those comments will be screened to give iconmakers privacy.
And now. The results.
BRAWL LIMS - Round Two - Challenge Two - RESULTS
Voted Off:
by kidoban with 15 votes
by flippybitch with 10 votes
We'll be very sad to see your icon-making abilities go.
Now for the Audience's Top Choice as well as the Mod's Choices.
Audience's Choice:
by masaharu_puri with 4 votes
There was a tie, so the tie breaker was the icon with the least number of negative votes.
Yumichika's Choice:
by whatsurwish
While this wasn't my first choice for mod's choice - the one I had orginally chosen recieved audience's choice - it is still a well made icon. The colors are rich and eye catching and make the subject stand out.
Kuchiki's Choice:
by eyesuphereplz
The lighting is really pretty, the text is perfect, and the cropping is really interesting. I like it! :D
The voting tally is as follows...
1. -3, +3
2. -6, +4
3. -4, +4
4. -2, +1
5. -15, +0
6. -4, +3
7. -1, +3
8. -4, +1
9. -3, +0
10. -6, +1
11. -4, +2
12. -6, +1
13. -10, +0
For those 11 still in the competition, I'll be putting up the next challenge shortly.