Prompt fic: RAT (part 2)
Prompt Fic: RAT
Title: ‘RAT’
Author: Brassband777
Characters: John, Sam (16), Dean (20)
Scenario: Teen!chester, discipline fic
Implement: hand, paddle
Summary: Sam rebels against John’s rules and Dean is forced to rat on his brother.
Author's Notes/Warnings: Written for Jet’s twenty-five prompts. Prompt word: ‘RAT’. Warning: Parental spanking of a teenager. Disclaimer: don’t own, just borrowing…
The next morning:
Sam was just finishing up his cereal when the phone rang once and stopped before ringing again half a minute later. He glowered into his bowl, knowing that it was his father.
Dean picked it up. “Hi, Dad, how’s the hunt going?”
Sam listened to the one-sided conversation, trying to fill in the blanks.
“That’s good, Dad, I’m glad.”
“Caleb did that? Wow, I didn’t think that was humanly possible.”
“No, sir, actually everything’s not okay here.”
Sam pricked up his ears. No, Dean wouldn’t!
“It’s Sam, he’s deliberately breaking curfew.”
Sam choked on his cereal. Dean cast a worried glance at his coughing, spluttering sibling, but after one look at the utter betrayal and hurt shining in Sam’s eyes, he turned away, feeling a knife twist in his own heart. He knew Sam would hate him for this, but if it was necessary for Sam to hate him in order to keep him safe, then so be it.
“Actually, Dad, I think he’s doing it just to get back at you.”
“Four times, sir.”
Sam had finally managed to get his coughing under control. He couldn’t believe Dean had done that to him! His Dad was gonna kill him!
Sam realised that his brother was holding the phone out to him.
“Dad wants to talk to you.” Dean avoided looking his brother in the eye, not wanting to see the condemnation there.
Sam hesitantly took the phone. “It’s me, Dad.”
John Winchester’s voice was shaking with controlled fury. “You’re grounded until further notice. I’ll deal with you when I get home. And in the meantime, if you take one more step out of that apartment without mine or Dean’s permission, I guarantee that you’ll get a bedtime spanking every day for a week and sitting will become a distant memory for you! Do I make myself clear, Samuel?”
Sam had to swallow down a nervous lump in his throat before he could answer. “Yes, sir.” He knew his father never made idle threats.
Dean took the phone back, but Sam tuned out their conversation. He was so dead!
Eventually, Dean hung up the phone and turned to look at his brother. Sam was slumped in his seat at the table, head down, staring at the tablecloth. He hesitatingly placed a hand on the teen’s shoulder.
“I’m really sorry, Sammy….” he began.
Sam immediately jerked away from his touch and stood up.
“Get the hell off me, Dean! You ratted me out….brothers don’t do that!”
“Listen, you gave me no choice. I couldn’t…”
Sam angrily cut him off. “You know what….just shut the hell up! You’re not my brother anymore!” With that, the sixteen year old stormed into the bathroom to get ready for school and slammed the door.
Dean stood shocked in the middle of the kitchen. Sam had just basically disowned him. Dean felt as if his brother had physically stabbed him. Maybe with time Sam would forgive him? Somehow, Dean seriously doubted it. Dean didn’t feel good at all about tattling on his brother, but he’d been backed into a corner and could see no other way out.
The next afternoon (Saturday):
Sam waited with trepidation for his father to arrive home. He revelled in the fact that he could lie on his back on his bed to read his book, knowing that when his Dad did eventually turn up, it would be a position that he wouldn’t want to adopt for quite some time.
He hadn’t spoken a single word to Dean since breakfast the day before. Dean had tried to talk to him several times and apologise, but Sam had studiously ignored every attempt at reconciliation.
When Sam heard his father’s truck pull up a few minutes later, his whole body tensed and his heart rate picked up in nervous anticipation. He heard his father and brother’s muffled voices, but couldn’t make out what was being said. A moment later there was a quiet knock on the bedroom door. Sam was surprised to see that it was Dean. Usually his older brother just barged in and never gave him the courtesy of knocking.
“Dad wants you in the sitting room.” Dean’s voice was quiet, subdued. “Look Sammy, I’m sorry you’re being punished, but…”
“It’s your fault I’m being punished! So don’t give me that sympathy crap!”
Dean was taken aback at the venom in his little brother’s voice and he felt like he’d been physically punched. In a way, Sam was right - Dean knew that if he hadn’t ratted on him, his brother wouldn’t be about to get the butt-warming of the century.
John Winchester was sitting on the sofa when his youngest entered. “Front and centre, Samuel!” he barked.
Sam shuffled over reluctantly to stand in front of his father. Physical resistance now would only land him in more trouble and he was already in deep enough as it was. Nonetheless, he met his father’s stern gaze defiantly.
John took one look at his youngest’s rebellious stance and realised the boy would be much more receptive to what he had to say when some of the teenaged-brattiness and attitude had been spanked out of him.
With that in mind, he gave a single command. “Jeans down.”
As Sam fumbled reluctantly with his button and zipper, John watched as his eldest crossed the room and entered the kitchen. Dean had no desire to witness his brother’s spanking, but as there was no door, merely a doorway separating the two rooms, he wouldn’t be able to escape from hearing it.
Once Sam had pushed his jeans down to his knees, John wasted no time in pulling the lanky teen across his lap and securing him in place. He immediately began swatting the boxer-clad backside in front of him.
Sam was usually very vocal during a spanking, unlike his older brother, but this time, Sam was determined not to give his father the satisfaction of knowing that he was hurting him. He clenched his fists and bit his lip to prevent himself from making a sound.
John pondered this new development. Was Sam trying to be stoic like Dean now? Somehow, he suspected it was just Sam being pig-headed.
After spanking for a couple of minutes, John paused, resting his hand on his youngest’s very warm bottom. “Why am I spanking you, Sam?”
Sam stubbornly didn’t respond. John sighed, before administering a flurry of harder spanks directly to Sam’s sensitive undercurve. Sam yelped in response and the first tears began to swim in his eyes, but he refused to let them fall.
“Because I broke curfew.”
John paused in his spanking again. “How many times did you break curfew?”
“Four,” sniffled Sam.
“Anything else?”
Sam frantically wracked his brains - he couldn’t think of anything else, but there must be or his Dad wouldn’t have asked. Sam evidently wasn’t thinking quickly enough, as his father brought his hand down twice more, extra hard.
“Oww! Dad, I’m Oww thinking!”
John decided to take pity on his youngest and help him out. He paused yet again in his spanking. “Who are you supposed to listen to when I’m not here?” he prompted.
“Dean…..I didn’t listen to Dean.”
“That’s right you didn’t. Now there’s a chain of command in this household - you follow my orders and then Dean’s and if you don’t, there are consequences!”
“It sucks being the youngest,” mumbled Sam under his breath, not realising that his father could still hear him.
John had to physically bite back a grin at that. Sam had no idea of the privileged position of being the baby of the family.
John pretended that he hadn’t heard Sam’s comment. “Now I don’t just give orders for the fun of it. I have a specific reason for every single order I give and I can guarantee you they’re good ones! Why do you think you have a curfew, Sam?”
Because you want to control me! thought Sam, but he had more sense than to say it.
John knew that his boy was still angry, it was evident in every line of his taught body. He wasn’t yet accepting the spanking - of course, he was accepting it physically, but only because he had no choice in the matter, but psychologically he was fighting it every step of the way. Sam was refusing to admit that he was in the wrong and was still pushing all the blame for his present painful predicament onto his father and older brother.
John sighed, knowing this particular spanking was far from over. He reached for Sam’s boxers and was unsurprised that his youngest tried to stop him. John wondered idly why neither of his sons had ceased doing that - hadn’t they realised yet that their attempt to keep either their last vestiges of dignity or the thin layer of protection was futile? He simply caught hold of Sam’s wrist and trapped it in the small of his back, before whipping the underwear down, revealing an already beet-red bottom.
John began spanking again in earnest, his swats harder and faster than they had been before. Sam couldn’t keep quiet now, despite his best efforts. He had no idea how Dean did it. Every single swat now elicited an ‘oww’, grunt or yelp from the teen. He also couldn’t hold back his tears.
In the kitchen, Dean buried his face in his hands. This was the vocal Sam that he was familiar with during a punishment. He just wanted the smacking sounds to stop. He could tell that his baby brother was crying from the intonation of his cries, but knew that for serious misbehaviour, John wouldn’t stop until they were properly sobbing. And breaking curfew deliberately was considered very serious, never mind breaking it four times.
At last, John felt the fight go out of his son and the sixteen-year-old went limp across his lap, as the first sobs escaped him. He immediately slowed and lessoned the force behind his swats, although Sam was too far gone to appreciate it.
“Okay, Sammy, shall I tell you why you have a curfew? To keep you safe! I love you more than anything and I couldn’t bear it if anything happened to you.”
Sam’s gut clenched - after all the horrible things he had said to his father lately, here was John telling him how much he loved him instead of berating him as he deserved. He had known full-well the consequence for breaking curfew, he just hadn’t banked on getting caught!
John continued, “And I know you’re blaming Dean, but that’s not fair, Sam. Dean didn’t break the rules, you did. Dean only told on you, because he couldn’t bear for you to get hurt either. You’re good at empathy, Sam, so put yourself in his shoes…what would you have done? And you think we treat you like a baby? That’s not true. I won’t let Dean out on the streets after dark either. You know that, and he’s twenty. I only let him out if I know exactly where he’s going and if he’s in the Impala.”
Sam’s anger and resentment had indeed been spanked out of him and the truth of his Dad’s words hit home. He finally admitted his responsibility to himself and his heart broke when he thought of how he’d treated Dean.
“I-I’m so-horry,” he sobbed.
Sam realised with relief that his father’s hard hand was no longer falling, but instead of being allowed to lie there and cry it all out, Sam suddenly found himself lifted into a standing position in front of his Dad. The teen didn’t just crave comfort after a spanking, he needed it. At the loss of physical contact he felt unexplainably abandoned and bereft. He looked up into his father’s stern gaze, tears flowing freely down his cheeks.
“I’m sorry, Sam, but your spanking’s not over yet. I’m going to fetch the paddle. That spanking was for breaking curfew once. You’re going to get two whacks each for the other three nights you broke it and a further four whacks for disobeying Dean.”
Sam shook his head. He couldn’t bear the thought of the paddle - the burn in his backside was already unbearable. The most he’d ever gotten with the paddle before after already being given a hand spanking was five when he’d disobeyed a direct order on a hunt, but now, he was apparently going to get ten.
“Pl-please, Dad, n-no more. I’m s-sorry.”
Dean stepped through the kitchen doorway and entered the sitting room, having heard every word of the conversation. He resolutely refused to look at his baby brother, unwilling to see the condemnation and hurt that would rightfully be there and focussed instead solely on his father.
“Come on, Dad, can’t you let him off the rest? I mean, I’m sure he’s learned his lesson.”
John wasn’t at all surprised that his eldest was pleading for leniency on his brother’s behalf, it was a common occurrence. “No, Dean. All actions and choices have consequences. He made his bed and now he has to lie in it.”
“Okay, fine. But what about the four swats for not listening to me? I mean, I’m the one he disobeyed, so surely I can waive that part of his punishment if I want?”
“Nice try, Dean. No, your brother’s getting what he’s earned, the full ten.”
Sam was watching his big brother, sobs still shaking his narrow frame. He didn’t deserve to have Dean defend him after how he’d treated him.
John retired to his bedroom to find the dreaded paddle. Dean wanted nothing more than to comfort his little brother, but knowing that his advances would be rejected, he returned to the kitchen and threw himself down on the chair. He’d tried, but changing John Winchester’s mind was like trying to move a mountain.
Sam was left standing alone in the sitting room. He felt totally lost. His logical mind told him that he’d be comforted when the spanking was over, but he needed it now! He was also desperate to make it up to Dean.
“Dean….” The word came out as a broken sob. Sam was not aware that he’d spoken it aloud.
In the kitchen, ever attuned to his baby brother’s needs and wants, Dean straightened in his chair. Sam was calling him. He hesitantly entered the sitting room, expecting Sam to ream him out for this being all his fault. Sam was standing, shoulders shaking, hugging himself protectively, underwear and jeans around his ankles. Dean cringed inwardly at the crimson hue of his brother’s derriere.
“Sammy?”
Sam spun at hearing Dean’s voice and automatically took a step towards him. His feet caught in the clothes tangled round his ankles and he would have face-planted on the sickly green carpet if Dean hadn’t made it to his side in a split second and caught him.
“Whoa, steady there, Tiger.”
Sam wrapped his arms around his older brother and buried his face in his shoulder. He was only a couple of inches shorter than Dean now.
“I’m so s-sorry, D-dean. Can you f-forgive me for the awful way I’ve treated y-you?” he sobbed.
Dean automatically tightened his arms around Sam’s quivering frame. He felt an enormous weight lift from him. Sam wasn’t mad at him anymore!
“Shhh, Sammy,” he soothed, “there’s nothing to forgive. I’m not surprised you were mad. You understand why I did it now though?”
Dean was relieved to feel Sam nod against his shoulder. He began to rub soothing circles on his back with one hand, desperate to get his brother to calm down a little.
John stood quietly in the hallway, the long wooden paddle in his hands. He leaned against the wall and waited, recognising that his sons needed this opportunity to kiss and make up so to speak.
Sam soaked up his brother’s comfort, dreading the moment when his Dad would return with the paddle. He suddenly realised that he was standing, hugging his brother while basically naked from the waist down. He blushed with embarrassment, though it wasn’t noticeable as his face was already flushed from crying. Dean worried for a moment when Sam suddenly pushed out of his embrace, until he realised what the teen was doing.
Sam kicked off his jeans, knowing that there was no way he would want them back on for the foreseeable future. Then figuring there was no painless way to do this, he gritted his teeth and yanked his underwear back up with one quick motion. He couldn’t prevent the resultant hiss that escaped him or the fresh tears that fell. He then returned to his brother’s waiting arms.
“You know, Sammy, you probably should have left them down.” Dean was thinking that if his Dad wanted to paddle his brother on the bare then that’s exactly what would happen. He was glad that his brother’s shaking was gradually lessening.
“I don’t want him to paddle me, Dean. It hurts so much already.”
“I know, Kiddo, but it’ll be over soon. You’ll be okay.”
Sam gave a half-laugh, half-sob. “Tell that to my backside, it begs to differ.”
Not wanting to prolong Sam’s punishment any longer, John stepped back into the room. Dean felt Sam stiffen and as he pulled back, he gave the teen’s shoulder a reassuring squeeze. “You’ll be fine,” he murmured, before returning to the kitchen to give his little brother some privacy.
John guided Sam over his lap once more, this time pinning Sam’s legs down with his own, knowing the physical reaction that the paddle would produce. He contemplated pulling down Sam’s boxers again, but decided he could spare his son that discomfort at least. It wasn’t as if the thin material would offer any protection from the wicked sting of the paddle.
Sam was still crying, but he was no longer sobbing. John sighed, knowing that his child would be reverted to that state very shortly.
He raised the paddle and snapped it down four times across the crest of Sam’s bottom. The teen bucked violently and cried out brokenly with each swat. He then quickly applied two swats to the back of Sam’s thighs, which had previously been untouched.
John paused for a moment to rub a gentle hand up the sobbing teenager’s back.
“Nearly done, Sammy. You’re doing brilliantly. Those were for breaking curfew and these last few are for disobeying your brother.”
John applied the final four strokes direct to Sam’s sit-spots and then threw the paddle down next to him.
Sam sobbed brokenly over his father’s lap, unable at first to focus on anything other than the pain. Slowly, he became aware of his father’s soothing voice and the gentle hand running up and down his spine.
When Sam’s sobs finally began to ebb, John pulled his youngest up until he was sitting on his lap and wrapped him in a tight embrace. Sam sniffled into his father’s shirt, savouring the comfort and security he provided. John continued to whisper reassurances into his son’s floppy chocolate-brown hair, which was nestled just under his chin.
At last, Sam raised his head. “I’m probably too big to be sitting on your knee, your legs must be dead by now,” he murmured sheepishly.
John chuckled. “You’ll never be too big, kiddo, my lap’s available any time you need it.” He pressed a kiss to Sam’s sweaty, damp temple. “You okay now, buddy?”
Sam nodded as he slowly extricated himself from his father’s embrace. “Yeah, I’m just kinda tired. Is it okay if I go lie down for a bit?”
John smiled. Sam always needed a nap after a spanking. “Sure thing, I’ll get you up when we’re gonna eat.”
After watching Sam disappear into the bedroom, he joined his eldest in the kitchen.
“He okay?” Dean sought out his father’s gaze immediately.
“Yeah, Dean. He’s fine. He’ll find sitting down uncomfortable for a few days, but that’s all. But he’s still grounded until further notice.”
Dean nodded, expecting nothing less from his father. He watched curiously as John pulled something out of his jacket pocket and put them on the table.
A grin lit up his features as he realised what they were. “You’re a big, old softie, you know that, Dad?”
Lying on the table were three entrance tickets for the Museum of Natural History.
“Well you said he really wanted to go.” John grinned, looking forward to pleasantly surprising the baby of the family. “I’ll give them to him when he wakes up. He may not be able to go with his class, but I thought we could go as a family on the morning we move out.”
Dean groaned. “You mean I’m gonna get dragged round a friggin museum? Can’t I wait in the car or something?”
“No you can’t, Dean. We’re doing this for your brother, so suck it up. You think I like museums?”
On second thoughts, Dean figured it wouldn’t be so bad - the exhibits would bore the hell out of him, but watching his geek brother doing something that would make him happy would be worth it.
THE END