I hope you don't mind constructive criticism...house_illreputeMarch 19 2007, 14:02:22 UTC
I really like this storyline. I've read all four parts of this in one sitting. Good job! I really like the tone of the fic and Draco and Neville's friendship. I'm not quite sure about Luna's characterization, but you've only given us a couple paragraphs of her, so not enough to make any real assessment. But there was something poignant about her line: And it had been so long since I had been able to just sit and watch life happenAlso, I meant to comment this before in one of the other parts, but you do a wonderful job at SHOWING us rather than TELLING us. There are little bits of characterizations that you pepper thru-out the story (in particular parts 2 & 3) that are wonderful for this! It's really easy to fall into the trap of prose-explanation when it comes to feelings and what someone was thinking or meaning, and so far, you've done well to not do that. Good job
( ... )
Re: I hope you don't mind constructive criticism...willfullyMarch 19 2007, 18:44:20 UTC
HEE. I adore constructive criticism, and I think you've made some very good points. I was planning to get this to a beta after it was finished, because it's a present and therefore I want it done quickly, but I'm starting to think maybe I should have done that now rather than later :D
Shall keep all of that in mind! And thank you for the review, as well!
I adore Luna, but you know this. And YES. There shall be Blood and Fire and bitching and I'm going to bug you about keeping Blood IC because I've never really tried to write her before, kay? ♥
Comments 18
Reply
Shall keep all of that in mind! And thank you for the review, as well!
Reply
The relationship between Harry and Draco is love. So much angst!
Love! And *Snuggles* :)
Reply
Haha! Love, angst, same thing. *adores!*
Reply
Your Neville is so calm....he's all grown up! :O awwww
Reply
(He could use a bit of snuggling. *snuggles and luffs on him*)
Reply
Reply
Reply
Yay Luna/Neville. I love Luna. Now let's have Fire run to his Blood and bitch and I will be a happy evil bunny.
Reply
I adore Luna, but you know this. And YES. There shall be Blood and Fire and bitching and I'm going to bug you about keeping Blood IC because I've never really tried to write her before, kay? ♥
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment