Leave a comment

Comments 37

kindness_says May 9 2011, 01:41:18 UTC
Is it like Alias where no one really dies?

Reply

bookelfe May 9 2011, 01:46:23 UTC
Well, it's always sort of complicated in the Doctor Who universe. Sometimes people die but it was a fakeout, and sometimes people die but then we see them again earlier in their own timeline, and sometimes people die but get brought back by the power of love, and sometimes people die and turn into robots, and sometimes people die and turn into sort of undead corpse-zombies and then die again after a few episodes, and . . . I mean, I could go on.

Reply

kindness_says May 9 2011, 01:52:28 UTC
...

=|

Reply

remindmeofthe May 9 2011, 02:27:52 UTC
I love this comment. Oh, Whoniverse.

Reply


oneechan19 May 9 2011, 02:28:59 UTC
How do you get four, because I only have three times.

But yes, they really need to stop killing off Rory.

Also: soooo much love for your icon.

Reply

bookelfe May 9 2011, 02:34:19 UTC
Okay, so there's the fakeout death Amy's Choice, and then the time he actually dies, and then the fakeout death in last week's episode - and yes, pretty much everybody had a fakeout death in last week's episode, but it was all the same very dramatic! - and then the death-by-drowning-and-resuscitation this time around. Not only is he beating Amy and Eleven, if I'm not mistaken he's beating Buffy!

And heee, thank you. :D

Reply

skelody May 9 2011, 03:01:08 UTC
I think the time he actually dies should count double. It was a very dead death. Mnemic death!

Reply

bookelfe May 9 2011, 03:09:35 UTC
It's true! It is definitely far and away the most dead anybody has been on Eleven's run so far.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

bookelfe May 9 2011, 02:43:01 UTC
It's true, they are kind of low on options for fakeout deaths! And Amy had her big fakeout death last season, but then again . . . so did Rory. (And then there was the season opener, which between the two parts managed to fakeout kill everybody, even River, which as you say shouldn't be possible!) I think clearly what this means is that they need to bring on some more regular cast members so the new people can have a turn fakeout dying, since clearly this is a plot device Moffat is not getting tired of all that soon. It doesn't actually irritate me, I just find it kind of hilarious.

And yes, your feelings are similar to mine. This episode is not going to rank among the greats or anything, but it was perfectly serviceable entertainment that maintained adorable character relationships and didn't permanently kill Rory, sometimes that's all I ask for!

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

bookelfe May 9 2011, 02:54:44 UTC
HAHAHA I WAS WAITING FOR SOMEONE TO DO THAT.

Reply


ceitfianna May 9 2011, 03:51:24 UTC
I love your icon and Rory.

They need to stop killing him, its not fair though more shirtless would be good. And more wet hair all around especially for the men because it makes them look sexy.

Also I'm totally with you on I have no idea what's going on, but I'm fine with that.

Reply

bookelfe May 9 2011, 03:56:24 UTC
Either they need to stop killing him or just go with the flow and have him die once an episode, because this is getting a bit ridiculous. *laughing*

Reply

ceitfianna May 9 2011, 03:58:41 UTC
It can be like in murder mysteries, are they all gathered together yet?

No, then there's still time to go, my parents would check how much time was left and go, that's not the real ending.

There's still half an hour left, its a fake out death!

Reply

bookelfe May 9 2011, 04:01:49 UTC
But then of course there's the dreaded CLIFFHANGER DEATH!

Reply


dictator_duck May 9 2011, 07:29:18 UTC
I'm sorry, I was going to leave a relevant comment but then I saw your icon. *_*

(It should explain enough that I first wrote that as "a relevant icon")

Okay, okay, relevancy: I watched it with my Heather (vs. anyone else's Heather THERE ARE SO MANY HEATHERS) and we pressed pause to just look at each other and go "really?" As in we actually said that.

Oh, Rory. You should dress like a dapper late 60s dude more often. And not die.

Reply

bookelfe May 9 2011, 13:29:41 UTC
I'm not going to lie, the icon pleases me a lot. Rory should dress like a dapper late 60s dude ALWAYS.

And hahaha yeah, I was pretty much sitting there giggling on my couch. OH MOFFAT, you love your fakeout deaths like some people love fakeout makeouts.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up