conuly
in
book_icons
I'm not miffed.
I was expecting this day for a while.
So, I've got a question. Exactly how much leeway should we allow for movies? To my mind, most animated films have very little in common with their bookish predecessors - but I have no intention of sorting through and saying "this animated film is good, this isn't". I don't want to spend my time judging on a case-by-case basis. I'm lazy. And while the recent animated film icons ARE from a film that's very close to the books (peter pan), other animated films aren't (the recent edition of "the three musketeers").
SO! Poll
Edit: If you don't want those icons, would a sister community (for book-movie icons, and no, not the contest comm that already exists) be okay? If I did that, though, I'd want to move ALL the movie icons there.
Edit again:
This is a very close poll. However, most people don't seem to have a problem with it, and the actual yesses are outvoting the nos by two votes. So unless there's a drastic change by morning, I'm cool with animated movie icons. Glad to see you all, thanks for playing, if I upset you, please accept my apologies. When I get money, I'll buy you some paid time or something.
So, I've got a question. Exactly how much leeway should we allow for movies? To my mind, most animated films have very little in common with their bookish predecessors - but I have no intention of sorting through and saying "this animated film is good, this isn't". I don't want to spend my time judging on a case-by-case basis. I'm lazy. And while the recent animated film icons ARE from a film that's very close to the books (peter pan), other animated films aren't (the recent edition of "the three musketeers").
SO! Poll
Edit: If you don't want those icons, would a sister community (for book-movie icons, and no, not the contest comm that already exists) be okay? If I did that, though, I'd want to move ALL the movie icons there.
Edit again:
This is a very close poll. However, most people don't seem to have a problem with it, and the actual yesses are outvoting the nos by two votes. So unless there's a drastic change by morning, I'm cool with animated movie icons. Glad to see you all, thanks for playing, if I upset you, please accept my apologies. When I get money, I'll buy you some paid time or something.