Well That's Surprising.
1. Joe Montana: 15 seasons, 40551 yds, 273 tds, 63.2 comp pct., 8 pro bowls, 2 NFL MVPs, 4 Superbowl championships.
2. John Elway: 16 seasons, 51475 yds, 300 tds, 56.8 comp pct., 9 pro bowls, 1 NFL MVP, 2 Superbowl championships, 148 wins (2nd all-time).
3. Brett Favre: 17 seasons, 61655 yds, 442 tds, 61.4 comp pct., 9 pro bowls, 3 NFL MVPs, 1 Superbowl championship, 275 consecutive games started, 160 wins(1st all-time).
4. Terry Bradshaw: 14 seasons, 27989 yds, 212 tds, 51.9 comp pct., 3 pro bowls, 4 Superbowl championships.
5. Dan Marino: 17 seasons, 61361 yds, 420 tds, 59.4 comp pct., 9 pro bowls, 1 NFL MVP. 147 wins (3rd all-time).