who dunnit?
watching harper's island and trying to figure out the killer here's what i got so far
don't read... contains spoilers for harper's island.
here is my thoughts on who dunnit. you see there is only ... abby, henry, trish, jimmy left [main characters wise] abby
charactersreasons not the killerreasons is the killer abby "the good girl"no way she could have killed katherine in epi 9[a] possible psychotic break after seeing her mother hanging from a tree
[b] possibly in love with henry jimmy "the old flame"what's the point of killing all those ppl. what grudge does he have against all of them? how does he know about hunter? [a] always there at the right time... also psychotic break?
[b] as for plot twists goes, could see it going towards him being abby's step brother and back when they were together and he was going to "take her camping" he was going to kill her
[c] had chance to kill off the others. though with henry when someone grabbed abby in the tunnels, but henry might be a part of it. was there in the hotel when katherine and beth diedmost likely suspecthenry "the groom"about the marry a millionaress... who would screw that up by killing her father and the priest the day before the wedding?[a] secretly in love abby?
[b] how did his parent's die? may be resentful
[c] standing over abby when she was with the gutted jd though doesn't remember how he got all scratched up. suspect trish "the bride"it's her wedding chloe "the flirt"was at the clinic when katherine and beth was killed[a] way too into the whole john wakefield thing. could be his kid? cal "the outsider"he has no qualms against anyone and was at the clinic patching up the sherif when katherine and beth were killedhe's in love with chloe and would do anything for her... maybe even kill...not likelysherif mills "the sherif"man of law...? he had a giant puncture hole in his left leg. how was he able to kill jd, katherine and beth? though he was in the cabin when cole died, but it could have been a rig that was set up to long before the sherif was hurt[a] all messed up after his wife's death. could be very vengeful sully "the groomsmen"[a] supposedly a coward and tried to leave the island at nite even though the killer threatened to kill madison if anyone leaves
[b] he's a lover not a killer[a] never trust a ho
shea "the maid of honor"[a] not angry enough to kill, i don't think
[b] her daughter madison
[c] why ruin her sister's wedding?
[d] when would she find the time to go to the island and set up all those traps?
[e] could not have killed katherine[a] she never wanted to be the stepford wife
[b] killed richard and her father and katherine for blaming them destroying her marriage, her life and idk what else... her dreams? and used the whole wakefield thing as a set up madison "the flower girl"way to young to start killingthough not the killer but implicates her family cuz she's a lil creepy kid and might be in cahoots with the killer or at the vary least shows that within her genes she's a bit iffyleast likelydanny "the college friend"no reasons to want to kill these ppl[a] you never know how they spin the story shane "the townie"[a] has not left the island. the sherif was tracking a copy cat that was going around the nation copying john wakefield.
[b] freaked out when he found katerine dead[a] him freaking out on katherine might be a false lead.
[b] has some serious anger issues maggie "the wedding planner"[a] no reason to ruin her inn's reputation. who would stay there ever again?
[b] qualms agains the others?
[c] planning a wedding. does she also have time to plan all those murders?[a] what secrets and skelotons is she hiding?
[b] owns the inn so would know about the tunnels underneath. has the chance for all the killings. who would suspect her? nikki "the biker chick"[a] no where near the wedding party. not part of the wedding party that was left in the inn when katherine and beth died.
[b] why kill her friend kelly?[a] found kelly dead
[b] could have snuck in through the tunnels and killed beth in the dark
.