Vid Rec: We Are All Connected

[beccatoria]

Okay, so, I still want to do an epic Doctor Who River Song reaction post because dude, that finale, omgz (there will be a vid, ijs).

BUT.

That will have to wait because this vid has stolen away all the space in my brain that can be devoted to wonder.

We Are All Connected by kiki_miserychicIt's a Stargate: Universe vid. I don't watch Stargate: Universe,

Comments

[beccatoria]

Yeah, I get that feeling too, though I'm not sure whether all the RTD stuff that got eaten by the cracks stayed eaten or not? I think they did though, cus Amy's parents would have if she hadn't remembered them and only Amy could do the "remembering to bring it back" thing. Or something.

It's weird - if you read interviews with Moffat he's very, very complimentary about RTD, like beyond what he needs to be to just be polite and professional - I genuinely get the impression he likes and appreciates him. But then, when I look at the show - if I just had to guess as to his feelings from the stories he's telling. Oy. I'd say he feels as strongly as me on the issue.

I thought Fry's comments were a real shame. Firstly just because there's nothing that says a kids' show can't be deep and meaningful. Skellig is a kids' book and it's also one of the most lovely things I've read in a long time. But he's also flat out incorrect. It's a family show. Or, to use a less loaded term because we don't all live in traditional nuclear family shows, it's a show for everyone. I understand that some stories suffer from that - but not this one. It's for everyone of every age. That means that it'll never be as dark and brutal as the Sopranos, but it also means that it shouldn't be as simplistic as the Teletubbies. I mean this series has a lot of humour and things to appeal to kids but it's also had episodes dealing with mental health issues, rather forward sexual innuendo and the possibility that the doctor is married to his own murderer. So you know, SUCK IT, FRY.

[gonzo21]

I think perhaps the BBC and RTD and his production crew thought they were making a kids show. I often heard them saying specifically, it was a kids show. (Which I think to large extent explained the simple stories RTD told. And also the contempt RTD had for older fans who criticised his story telling, because he seemed to default to 'what are you doing watching this anyway, its a kids show!')

But yes, I agree. It's a family show.

And its possible isn't it, that the entire RTD era has now been Moffed out of canon. I doubt it though. But the possibility amuses me.