My official response to the debate.

Oct 01, 2004 11:52

My responses to some quotations, and my general thoughts:

Read the entire transcript here

He said what?? )

Leave a comment

thisficklemob October 1 2004, 09:33:02 UTC
And, I meant to say, ONLY the Ministry of Oil was guarded.

And I found the speech I was looking for!

A relevant portion:

Before the war on Iraq began, the Office of Reconstruction and Humanitarian Assistance (ORHA) sent the Pentagon a list of 16 crucial sites to protect. The National Museum was second on that list. Yet the Museum was not just looted, it was desecrated. It was a repository of an ancient cultural heritage. Iraq as we know it today was part of the river valley of Mesopotamia. The civilisation that grew along the banks of the Tigris and the Euphrates produced the world’s first writing, first calendar, first library, first city, and, yes, the world’s first democracy. King Hammurabi of Babylon was the first to codify laws governing the social life of citizens. It was a code in which abandoned women, prostitutes, slaves, and even animals had rights. The Hammurabi code is acknowledged not just as the birth of legality, but the beginning of an understanding of the concept of social justice. The US government could not have chosen a more inappropriate land in which to stage its illegal war and display its grotesque disregard for justice.

At a Pentagon briefing during the days of looting, Secretary Rumsfeld, Prince of Darkness, turned on his media cohorts who had served him so loyally through the war. "The images you are seeing on television, you are seeing over and over and over, and it’s the same picture, of some person walking out of some building with a vase, and you see it twenty times and you say, ‘My god, were there that many vases? Is it possible that there were that many vases in the whole country?’."

Laughter rippled through the press room. Would it be alright for the poor of Harlem to loot the Metropolitan Museum? Would it be greeted with similar mirth?

The last building on the ORHA list of 16 sites to be protected was the Ministry of Oil.It was the only one that was given protection. Perhaps the occupying army thought that in Muslim countries lists are read upside down? Television tells us that Iraq has been ‘liberated’ and that Afghanistan is well on its way to becoming a paradise for women-thanks to Bush and Blair, the 21st century’s leading feminists. In reality, Iraq’s infrastructure has been destroyed. Its people brought to the brink of starvation. Its food stocks depleted. And its cities devastated by a complete administrative breakdown. Iraq is being ushered in the direction of a civil war between Shias and Sunnis. Meanwhile, Afghanistan has lapsed back into the pre-Taliban era of anarchy, and its territory has been carved up into fiefdoms by hostile warlords.

But really, read the whole thing. I've spent a lot of time this week reading Roy's essays, and I really quite adore her.

Reply

bandgeek October 1 2004, 10:26:17 UTC
Wow. That's great. Thanks for turning me on to some great reading! :)

Reply

thisficklemob October 1 2004, 10:47:47 UTC
You're welcome. I took three books of Roy essays out of the library last week, and I want to make a big meta-post about it... about her writing, and what's right and wrong with America, and such... but it requires higher levels of organizational and expressive thought than I can manage at the moment. *g*

Reply

bandgeek October 3 2004, 08:33:48 UTC
I can totally relate. I have all these thoughts, but when it comes to actually expressing them, all I can do is grunt ineffectually. ;)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up