Comments | band_claim2: Debate!

empty_jester in band_claim2

Debate!

Jan 14, 2007 13:26

Here's one for y'all to mull over ( Read more... )

Back to all threads

shamoke January 15 2007, 19:33:36 UTC

Okay, don't totally quote me on this, because there's no way I can always stand by this. I'm sure I could say my favorite, but... One best? It's close to an impossible question. Anyway, I'm going to try to answer it.

Weezer-Pinkerton

Yeah. I'm pretty sure I nailed it as close as I could.

empty_jester January 15 2007, 19:44:19 UTC

It is a wicked difficult topic, but I think you nailed a pretty good choice. Do you think they can pull things back together after the "Make Believe" debacle and be as cool as they once were if they decide to stay together?

shamoke January 15 2007, 20:11:15 UTC

Simply put, no. They can't make good music without Matt Sharp, I believe. There are a few good songs on each album without Matt Sharp, but they're nothing compared to the first two albums. They just don't have the same feel. I think that if Rivers wants to continue with a band, he should not be with Weezer.

mud_and_bleach January 16 2007, 01:03:42 UTC

They'll never be as good without Sharp but they definitely are still one of the most awesome bands out there... case in point, the SS2k songs.

shamoke January 16 2007, 01:13:47 UTC

Eh.

They're not even half as good without Sharp. :/

cardboardtowns January 15 2007, 20:06:54 UTC

this was what i was about to put. BRILLIANCE.

mud_and_bleach January 16 2007, 01:02:43 UTC

Stole mine. Pinkerton is by far one of the greatest albums ever.

Back to all threads