Challenge Ten Results
Thank you to the people who voted. The spread of votes shows how great all our icons are but sadly we have to say goodbye to one more person before the final challenge.
The following participant has been voted out...
&
by michelle_sarah
(+2/-7) + (+4/-3) = -5 +1 = -4
I'm so sorry to see you go but thank you for taking part - and congratulations on making it this far! :D
People's Choice:
by zippogirl
+10/00
Tally:
#1: -3 +2 = -1
#2: -5 +1 = -4
#3: +10
#4: -7 +2 = -5
#5: -3 +4 = +1
#6: -2 +5 = +3
#7: -2 +4 = +2
#8: -8 +2 = -6
Maker totals:
michelle_sarah (Icons 4 & 5): -5 +1 = -4
stolenglimpse (Icons 1 & 6): -1 +3 = +2
sugarfixx (Icons 2 & 7): -4 +2 = -2
zippogirl (Icons 3 & 8): +10 -6 = +4
Direct Link To Voting
Positive Comments
[Please Note: Not all positive votes provided a comment so the number of comments here does not equal the number of positive votes.]
Favourite - 1 - The texture use is nice. The red in the icon also looks nice. The text works as well.
Favourite - #3. Great use of texture and text placement.
Favourite - #3 beautiful colouring and composition
Favourite - 3 - love the coloring of the image with the green texture and I love the blending, the way the sand on the beach fades into the texture. Nice text placement too
Favourite - #3 beautiful coloring
Favourite - 3 - you can really feel the emotion, also great coloring
Favourite - #3, great use of textures.
Favourite - 4 - I love the blue colouring
Favourite - 5, the vibrant colors, the text and font choice are perfect
Favourite - 6 - The brightness/contrast levels are just right. The texture use and text also work well with this icon.
Favourite - 6 - great use of text/font
Favourite - #6 georgous lighting and pic/words arrangement
Favourite - #07: Love the blending and the tiny text
Favourite - 7 i really like the image choices and the blending. the lighting works great and it's an interesting texture placement. like the soft gray floral touch.
Favourite - 7 - love the blending
Favourite - #7 - good composition and use of stock images/texture.
Favourite - #8 i love the subtlety of this with the shadow, great composition
Constructive Criticism
Leave a comment with your icon number to get your feedback. All comments are screened but you'll be able to see them if you receive email notifications. If you don't receive notifications then leave your email address and I'll send your comments via email.
We're now down to the final three! The next challenge, i.e the final challenge will be up shortly! :D
The following participant has been voted out...
&
by michelle_sarah
(+2/-7) + (+4/-3) = -5 +1 = -4
I'm so sorry to see you go but thank you for taking part - and congratulations on making it this far! :D
People's Choice:
by zippogirl
+10/00
Tally:
#1: -3 +2 = -1
#2: -5 +1 = -4
#3: +10
#4: -7 +2 = -5
#5: -3 +4 = +1
#6: -2 +5 = +3
#7: -2 +4 = +2
#8: -8 +2 = -6
Maker totals:
michelle_sarah (Icons 4 & 5): -5 +1 = -4
stolenglimpse (Icons 1 & 6): -1 +3 = +2
sugarfixx (Icons 2 & 7): -4 +2 = -2
zippogirl (Icons 3 & 8): +10 -6 = +4
Direct Link To Voting
Positive Comments
[Please Note: Not all positive votes provided a comment so the number of comments here does not equal the number of positive votes.]
Favourite - 1 - The texture use is nice. The red in the icon also looks nice. The text works as well.
Favourite - #3. Great use of texture and text placement.
Favourite - #3 beautiful colouring and composition
Favourite - 3 - love the coloring of the image with the green texture and I love the blending, the way the sand on the beach fades into the texture. Nice text placement too
Favourite - #3 beautiful coloring
Favourite - 3 - you can really feel the emotion, also great coloring
Favourite - #3, great use of textures.
Favourite - 4 - I love the blue colouring
Favourite - 5, the vibrant colors, the text and font choice are perfect
Favourite - 6 - The brightness/contrast levels are just right. The texture use and text also work well with this icon.
Favourite - 6 - great use of text/font
Favourite - #6 georgous lighting and pic/words arrangement
Favourite - #07: Love the blending and the tiny text
Favourite - 7 i really like the image choices and the blending. the lighting works great and it's an interesting texture placement. like the soft gray floral touch.
Favourite - 7 - love the blending
Favourite - #7 - good composition and use of stock images/texture.
Favourite - #8 i love the subtlety of this with the shadow, great composition
Constructive Criticism
Leave a comment with your icon number to get your feedback. All comments are screened but you'll be able to see them if you receive email notifications. If you don't receive notifications then leave your email address and I'll send your comments via email.
We're now down to the final three! The next challenge, i.e the final challenge will be up shortly! :D