(no subject)

Dec 01, 2007 19:44

Unfortunately we have to say goodbye to the following participant...


&
by sugarfixx
00/-9 + +5/-4 = -8

I'm so sorry to see you go but thank you for taking part! :)

People's Choice:

by prettyadorable
+10/-2

Tally:
#1: -5+2 = -3
#2: -2+10 = +8
#3: -9
#4: +5-1 = +4

#5: -2+5 = +3
#6: -4+5 = +1
#7: -7+4 = -3
#8: -4+3 = -1

Direct Link To Voting

Positive Comments
[Please Note: Not all positive votes provided a comment so the number of comments here does not equal the number of positive votes.]
Favourite - 01: Overall well done; great contrast and simple.
Favourite - 02 - I like the cropping, just be careful with excessive use of brush text.
Favorite: 2 I like the crop, and the way the text was used, even if it's hard to read
Favourite - #2 - The cap is gorgeous and I love how the text just 'pops' from the icon.
Favourite - 02 - The texture/text/brush is brilliant, and goes extremely well with the icon. The colouring is a bit dark, but the composition is brilliant.
Favourite - #4 I really love the cap chosen and the text. So pretty!
Favourite - 4 - interesting crop
Favourite - 4,the brightness level is nice. also like the placement of the text
Favourite: #4 - Uses text nicely and the cropping is excellent.
Favourite - 5: THE BEST colouring, the light white stuff could have been different though =)
Favourite - 5 - love the colouring and lighting
Favorite: 6 the coloring is beautiful, and the text fits so well
Favourite #6 - The colouring is very pretty. :)
Favourite - 06 - I like the coloring, just be careful with excessive use of brush text.
Favourite - 6, beautiful crop and text placement. coloring is also perfect along with slight texture use
Favourite - 06 - Beautiful colouring.
Favourite - 7- good composition
Favourite - #7 I love the rounded corners, very nice.
Favourite - 07: Great coloring and nice touch with the text on the side.
Favourite: #8 - Nice cropping and colouring.
Favourite - #8 - Perfect! I love the size of the cap, the colouring, how the background has been blurred and the text. This icon is gorgeous.

Other Comments
[i.e. These icons were not voted for either positively or negatively but feedback was left for the maker.]
Extra comment - #5 - This is really pretty! I love the colouring that has been used, the icon is so vibrant.

Constructive Criticism
Leave a comment with your icon number to get your feedback. All comments are screened but you'll be able to see them if you receive email notifications. If you don't receive notifications then leave your email address and I'll send your comments via email.

We're now down to the final three! The next challenge, i.e the final challenge will be up shortly! :D

round two, challenge eleven, results

Previous post Next post
Up