Challenge Three Results

Oct 04, 2007 20:42

Unfortunately we have to say goodbye to the following participant...


by crystalsc
+1/-7
I'm really sorry to see you go but thanks for taking part and I hope you stick around for voting and the special eliminated challenge later on! :)

People's Choice:

by ba4ever
+5/-1

Mod's Choice:

by prettyadorable
I love the creative texture use.

Tally:
#1: -4+1 = -3
#2: -2+1 = -1
#3: -4+1 = -3
#4: -1+5 - +4
#5: -7+1 = -6
#6: -4+2 = -2

Direct Link to Voting

Positive Comments
[Please Note: Not all positive votes provided a comment so the number of comments here does not equal the number of positive votes.]
#4, the cropping is original and the glowing stars texture/brush fits nicely.
Fave: 2 Nice texture, good use of tiny text, like the colouring, contrast and use of shadows (possibly from the light texture?).
3. the image is clear and crisp, nicely cropped
04 - the icon has unique cropping and good text placement as well as goo use of textyres as they enhance the icon without detracting from it.
#04 - The cropping of the image is perfect. The colour and texture really delves into the romance Buffy and Angel shared.
04: creative cropping and use of picture. Also text fits well the whole composition.

Negative Comments
Leave a comment with your icon number to get your feedback. All comments are screened but you'll be able to see them if you receive email notifications. If you don't receive notifications then leave your email address and I'll send your comments via email.

The next challenge will be up shortly.

round two, results, challenge three

Previous post Next post
Up