Welcome to Attackademia: Beyond Thunderdome.

[arcana_mundi]

Only one rule: post only quotations from published material or amusing glosses - do not attempt to start fresh, UNPUBLISHED fights with each other in the comments while attempting to justify, explain, or temporize for, an attackademic in your field.

Seriously, don't. No point, on account of how anything that starts to look serious or pedantic will

Comments

[sebastianm]

A compound question: are reviews of scholarly work fair game, or just snarkiness within the works themselves?

[arcana_mundi]

TOTALLY fair game! That's often where the gloves really come off. Best of all are reviews that lead to sparring that goes on for months in the letters column, or actual blood feuds between institutions.