Book 1, Chapter 5: Voting
(Current # of votes: 14/15)
IF YOU ARE HAVING TROUBLE COMMENTING ON LIVEJOURNAL ENTRIES, PLEASE E-MAIL ME YOUR VOTES. My e-mail is helium.lost[at]gmail.com (replace the [at] with @). Please title the e-mail atla_battle: Chapter 5 Vote or something similar, and please include your Livejournal username if it's different from your e-mail address.
Yay, we got all our entries! ^^
Bumi has withdrawn for personal reasons, so Azula has a default win. Azula's icon is still included in the voting for posterity's sake, but no votes will actually go toward it.
This week, you will be submitting three votes, one for each pair. Your vote is for the icon that you feel is OF LESSER QUALITY, and you must provide a reason as to why you feel that that icon is of lesser quality. As usual, no petty votes; all critiques must be made based on the aesthetics and technical skills displayed in each icon.
The icons are slightly mixed in that, for some pairs, I inverted the order displayed by the IDs, and that in some pairs, I didn't. So don't try to guess who made the icon by the order that the icons are listed ^^;
For the iconmakers included in this round, when you get to your pair, do not vote. Instead, type in the character you play.
You are still allowed to leave general comments for icons. Just put them at the end of the vote ^^
Example:
Pair #33: #15 - The use of light textures overwhelms the icon, and it becomes difficult to see who/what the subject is.
Pair #34: Teo
Pair #35: #20 - The overuse of textures clutters up the icon.
General Comments:
#16 - The text is done very nicely in this icon!
PAIR #1
PAIR #2
Ursa vs. Toph
Katara vs. Appa
1
2
3
4
Challenge: Grungy/Antique
Challenge: Duplicated Image
PAIR #3
PAIR #4
Ozai vs. Sokka
Azula vs. Bumi
5
6
7
8
(withdrawal)
Challenge: Extreme Close-Up
Challenge: Image Provided
Here's a form for you to copy and paste into your comment to make things a bit easier for both you and me:
VOTING IS CLOSED FOR PAIRS 2 AND 3; HOWEVER, MORE VOTES ARE NEEDED FOR PAIR 1. You may only vote for that pair now.
Remember, you are voting for the icon of *lesser* quality.
Pair #1: 1 or 2 - Explanation
General Comments:
(optional)
Have fun, and good luck! Voting ends at either 15 votes or 5:00PM PST on Sunday, May 27, whichever comes first.
- hl
IF YOU ARE HAVING TROUBLE COMMENTING ON LIVEJOURNAL ENTRIES, PLEASE E-MAIL ME YOUR VOTES. My e-mail is helium.lost[at]gmail.com (replace the [at] with @). Please title the e-mail atla_battle: Chapter 5 Vote or something similar, and please include your Livejournal username if it's different from your e-mail address.
Yay, we got all our entries! ^^
Bumi has withdrawn for personal reasons, so Azula has a default win. Azula's icon is still included in the voting for posterity's sake, but no votes will actually go toward it.
This week, you will be submitting three votes, one for each pair. Your vote is for the icon that you feel is OF LESSER QUALITY, and you must provide a reason as to why you feel that that icon is of lesser quality. As usual, no petty votes; all critiques must be made based on the aesthetics and technical skills displayed in each icon.
The icons are slightly mixed in that, for some pairs, I inverted the order displayed by the IDs, and that in some pairs, I didn't. So don't try to guess who made the icon by the order that the icons are listed ^^;
For the iconmakers included in this round, when you get to your pair, do not vote. Instead, type in the character you play.
You are still allowed to leave general comments for icons. Just put them at the end of the vote ^^
Example:
Pair #33: #15 - The use of light textures overwhelms the icon, and it becomes difficult to see who/what the subject is.
Pair #34: Teo
Pair #35: #20 - The overuse of textures clutters up the icon.
General Comments:
#16 - The text is done very nicely in this icon!
PAIR #1
PAIR #2
Ursa vs. Toph
Katara vs. Appa
1
2
3
4
Challenge: Grungy/Antique
Challenge: Duplicated Image
PAIR #3
PAIR #4
Ozai vs. Sokka
Azula vs. Bumi
5
6
7
8
(withdrawal)
Challenge: Extreme Close-Up
Challenge: Image Provided
Here's a form for you to copy and paste into your comment to make things a bit easier for both you and me:
VOTING IS CLOSED FOR PAIRS 2 AND 3; HOWEVER, MORE VOTES ARE NEEDED FOR PAIR 1. You may only vote for that pair now.
Remember, you are voting for the icon of *lesser* quality.
Pair #1: 1 or 2 - Explanation
General Comments:
(optional)
Have fun, and good luck! Voting ends at either 15 votes or 5:00PM PST on Sunday, May 27, whichever comes first.
- hl