Yes I dug the movie, but c'mon

Aug 25, 2010 07:25


Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 14

ylno_yaw_eno August 25 2010, 13:07:26 UTC
Hahaha love it!

Reply


swashbucklr August 25 2010, 13:51:32 UTC
Ramona Flowers was best described as a MacGuffin With Boobs. (Which sounds like someone you'd get at McDonalds.)

Also, I've had the thought, and read a number of people who agree, that the movie is actually supposed to be from Scott's perspective, which both makes him an unreliable narrator, and also makes more sense as far as Ramona is concerned. After all, Scott doesn't really seem to have much of a grasp on empathy.

Still, the story would have been better if we understood her a little more.

Reply

Indeed. rustycoon August 25 2010, 15:05:50 UTC
It also neatly explains Ramona's mystical powers over reality (see also: melting snow while she rollerblades... IN THE SNOW).

Really, between Michael Cena and the cardboard handling of Ramona I found every other character in the film more interesting (except Gideon who also received cardboard handling).

Reply

asivt August 25 2010, 15:23:34 UTC
I don't disagree, but it still pisses me off when movie executives look at a comic book and say "Y'know what's entirely unnecessary? The leading lady's story arc and personality. As long as the actress who plays her is hot, no one will care that we completely neutered her character."

I'd be less irritated if I couldn't have made this same comic for the movie versions of Storm and the Silk Spectre too.

Reply

paranoiattaque August 25 2010, 17:06:24 UTC
oh my god the way watchmen handled silk spectre and sally jupiter was GODDAMN ENRAGING. OH MY GOD I CAN'T EVEN.

Reply


paranoiattaque August 25 2010, 17:03:58 UTC
haha, this is one of my main problems with that movie.. besides the complete ADHD family guy-style humour. A+++

Reply


meepalicious August 25 2010, 21:50:02 UTC
A+

Reply


faerieboots August 27 2010, 15:03:23 UTC
I was very frustrated with this aspect of the movie, too--there is simply no plausible reason given why this woman would hook up with Scott Pilgrim.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up