challenge 3-1: voting
Please note that for this round we only be eliminating three icons per challenge as well as picking only one favorite.
★ Voting for challenge 3-1 will end at Sunday, November 25, 2007 at 11:00 PM EST.
★ You are voting for 3 (THREE) icons of LESSER QUALITY to be eliminated, and 1 icon that is YOUR FAVORITE for People's Choice awards. For the elimination icons, please judge based on overall technique and aesthetic quality, NOT personal preferences. We reserve the right to void any vote we feel is unfair or petty. You do not have to give a reason for your FAVORITE icon choices (though it is encouraged), but YOU MUST GIVE A REASON FOR YOUR ELIMINATIONS.
★ Do NOT vote for your own icons (for either category) and don't feel obligated to not vote for your friends' icons, etc. Keep things as objective as possible!
★ ANYONE CAN VOTE. You do not have to be a contestant or anything, so VOTE AWAY!
★ Here is an example vote for you to follow (3 eliminations, 1 favorites):
#101 - The excessive use of textures over-powers the icon.
#102 - The icon is too washed out overall.
#103 - The image quality is poor, too much dithering.
Favorite - #108 because I love the cropping and the coloring is beautiful!
★ Finally, if you have any questions, post it in the F.A.Q. entry here.
Please look very carefully at each and every icon, and be EXTREMELY CAUTIOUS with the numbers that you pick! It's very easy to accidentally vote off the wrong icon #, and such errors can be costly. Us mods will try to re-check each and every vote-off (making sure the reason matches the icon, etc), but we can't correct everything. So please double-check your votes before you post them!
Also, all votes are screened and will remain anonymous, so please be honest in your critiques.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Skips: eriyuu*, pinkosa*, hwighting*, asdaaas*, moumo*, junpi, oulan, incoming*, youenvyme, chakuura, and hitonigiri*
* confirmed
★ Voting for challenge 3-1 will end at Sunday, November 25, 2007 at 11:00 PM EST.
★ You are voting for 3 (THREE) icons of LESSER QUALITY to be eliminated, and 1 icon that is YOUR FAVORITE for People's Choice awards. For the elimination icons, please judge based on overall technique and aesthetic quality, NOT personal preferences. We reserve the right to void any vote we feel is unfair or petty. You do not have to give a reason for your FAVORITE icon choices (though it is encouraged), but YOU MUST GIVE A REASON FOR YOUR ELIMINATIONS.
★ Do NOT vote for your own icons (for either category) and don't feel obligated to not vote for your friends' icons, etc. Keep things as objective as possible!
★ ANYONE CAN VOTE. You do not have to be a contestant or anything, so VOTE AWAY!
★ Here is an example vote for you to follow (3 eliminations, 1 favorites):
#101 - The excessive use of textures over-powers the icon.
#102 - The icon is too washed out overall.
#103 - The image quality is poor, too much dithering.
Favorite - #108 because I love the cropping and the coloring is beautiful!
★ Finally, if you have any questions, post it in the F.A.Q. entry here.
Please look very carefully at each and every icon, and be EXTREMELY CAUTIOUS with the numbers that you pick! It's very easy to accidentally vote off the wrong icon #, and such errors can be costly. Us mods will try to re-check each and every vote-off (making sure the reason matches the icon, etc), but we can't correct everything. So please double-check your votes before you post them!
Also, all votes are screened and will remain anonymous, so please be honest in your critiques.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Skips: eriyuu*, pinkosa*, hwighting*, asdaaas*, moumo*, junpi, oulan, incoming*, youenvyme, chakuura, and hitonigiri*
* confirmed