Round 01 - Challenge 02 - Results
Sorry this took so long to get up!
Eliminated:
- misses_turner [07 votes]
Please stick around for the special challenge and for voting! ♥
---
People's choice:
- mata090680 [03 votes]
---
Mod's Choice
- phantom_phan06
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Votes:
[N = Negative votes & P = Positive votes]
01] - weasleyangel - N = 3/P = 0
[x] "I can't tell if the icon is a little oversharpened or a little too blurry, but either way, just not appealing to the eyes."
[x] "the picture is too contrasted"
[x] "the image's shadows are too strong and the icon looks bleached of color"
02] - gossymer - N = 0/P = 1
[x] "love the colors"
03] - misses_turner - N = 7/P = 0
[x] "random light splotches texture is not complimentary to the icon."
[x] "The light texture seems out of place with the icon, perhaps some text would have melded better in the icon."
[x] "the light texture is misplaced"
[x] "the dot light texture seems out of place and Aragorn could use more light contrast in his face"
[x] "Lovely colouring, but the blurry white dots are kinda distracting and random."
[x] "The coloring, especially on his face, is too red/pink. The light dot texture seems randomly chosen, too, and doesn't match the icon."
[x] "the image does not have much contrast and the colors don't pop"
04] - lunglock - N = 0/P = 0
05] - mata090680 - N = 0/P = 3
[x] "well executed blending....nice text-work too."
[x] "Really great icon. Perfect use of text & blending. The coloring is amazing. "
[x] "The concept is neat and executed nicely. Love the text choice and how it stands out while blending in with the icon."
06] - utkari02 - N = 6/P = 0
[x] "the text is too large for the icon"
[x] "the quality of the text detracts from the icon overall"
[x] "The blue takes away some of the contrast and the writing is pixelated."
[x] "The texture makes it too light and it looks as if it should be a darker feeling icon, that and the crop is odd"
[x] "The text stands out too much, due to the bright white color and its size. It's also looking somewhat choppy."
[x] "the coloring seems off and the text does not really match the image"
07] - andemaiar - N = 2/P = 2
[x] "aragorn cropping is awkward."
[x] "The crop is odd, makes it look like he rules her"
[x] "I'm seriously in love with the whole idea, the composition and the cropping."
[x] Positive [No comment]
08] - phantom_phan06 - N = 6/P = 0
[x] "too many textures that overpower the icon."
[x] "While I love the use of the texture and the text, Aragorns' face is just too orange."
[x] "the texture is overpowering"
[x] "Great change of (colour-)pace, but Aragorn could've used more contrast to 'pop out' more."
[x] "The texture makes the icon look too busy."
[x] "The texture overpowers the icon."
09] - so_severus - N = 0/P = 2
[x] Positive [No comment]
[x] Positive [No comment]
Participants Status
The following people are still in the contest. If you're name is not in this list, it means you have been eliminated/disqualified.
andemaiar
gossymer
lunglock
mata090680
mesnica
phantom_phan06
so_severus
utkari02
weasleysangel
Thank you to all who participated in the challenge and voting.
A new challenge will be put up soon.
Eliminated:
- misses_turner [07 votes]
Please stick around for the special challenge and for voting! ♥
---
People's choice:
- mata090680 [03 votes]
---
Mod's Choice
- phantom_phan06
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Votes:
[N = Negative votes & P = Positive votes]
01] - weasleyangel - N = 3/P = 0
[x] "I can't tell if the icon is a little oversharpened or a little too blurry, but either way, just not appealing to the eyes."
[x] "the picture is too contrasted"
[x] "the image's shadows are too strong and the icon looks bleached of color"
02] - gossymer - N = 0/P = 1
[x] "love the colors"
03] - misses_turner - N = 7/P = 0
[x] "random light splotches texture is not complimentary to the icon."
[x] "The light texture seems out of place with the icon, perhaps some text would have melded better in the icon."
[x] "the light texture is misplaced"
[x] "the dot light texture seems out of place and Aragorn could use more light contrast in his face"
[x] "Lovely colouring, but the blurry white dots are kinda distracting and random."
[x] "The coloring, especially on his face, is too red/pink. The light dot texture seems randomly chosen, too, and doesn't match the icon."
[x] "the image does not have much contrast and the colors don't pop"
04] - lunglock - N = 0/P = 0
05] - mata090680 - N = 0/P = 3
[x] "well executed blending....nice text-work too."
[x] "Really great icon. Perfect use of text & blending. The coloring is amazing. "
[x] "The concept is neat and executed nicely. Love the text choice and how it stands out while blending in with the icon."
06] - utkari02 - N = 6/P = 0
[x] "the text is too large for the icon"
[x] "the quality of the text detracts from the icon overall"
[x] "The blue takes away some of the contrast and the writing is pixelated."
[x] "The texture makes it too light and it looks as if it should be a darker feeling icon, that and the crop is odd"
[x] "The text stands out too much, due to the bright white color and its size. It's also looking somewhat choppy."
[x] "the coloring seems off and the text does not really match the image"
07] - andemaiar - N = 2/P = 2
[x] "aragorn cropping is awkward."
[x] "The crop is odd, makes it look like he rules her"
[x] "I'm seriously in love with the whole idea, the composition and the cropping."
[x] Positive [No comment]
08] - phantom_phan06 - N = 6/P = 0
[x] "too many textures that overpower the icon."
[x] "While I love the use of the texture and the text, Aragorns' face is just too orange."
[x] "the texture is overpowering"
[x] "Great change of (colour-)pace, but Aragorn could've used more contrast to 'pop out' more."
[x] "The texture makes the icon look too busy."
[x] "The texture overpowers the icon."
09] - so_severus - N = 0/P = 2
[x] Positive [No comment]
[x] Positive [No comment]
Participants Status
The following people are still in the contest. If you're name is not in this list, it means you have been eliminated/disqualified.
andemaiar
gossymer
lunglock
mata090680
mesnica
phantom_phan06
so_severus
utkari02
weasleysangel
Thank you to all who participated in the challenge and voting.
A new challenge will be put up soon.