Round 02 - Challenge 10: Final - Results

[lunglock]

ROUND 02 FINAL RESULTS

THIRD PLACE
mata090680!













SET C
7.
8.
9.

TALLY
Negative votes: 3
Positive votes ~ #7 = 1
Overall: 3- + 1+ = 2-

SECOND PLACE
idril_lalaith!











SET B
4.
5.
6.

TALLY
Negative votes: 2
Positive votes ~ #4 = 1
Overall: 2- + 1+ = 1-

FIRST PLACE
_elissabeth_!








SET A
1.
2.
3.

TALLY
Negative votes: 0
Positive votes ~ #1 = 2 + #3 = 1.
Overall: 0- + 3+ = 3+

[N = Negative votes & P = Positive votes]

SET A] - _elissabeth_ - N = 0/P = 3
[x] #1 - "I really like the crop and overall design."
[x] #1 - "The crop is good, the text is appropriate, and I love the brush on the bottom."
[x] #3 - "Has an awesome pose and look to it, very expressive and clear."

SET B] - idril_lalaith - N = 2/P = 1
[x] "I really like #4, but 5 & 6 have less interesting crops. The font and verbage on 6 is distracting to me."
[x] "the colouring of icons 2 and 3 is too strong and dark, first icon,btw, is perfect"
[x] #5 - Positive [No comment]

SET C] - mata090680 - N = 3/P = 1
[x] "generally, all three icons are not particularly crisp and the cropping and colouring are bland."
[x] "The images used, especially in the first two icons, are a little pixelated and indistinct."
[x] "Aragorn's too tiny on the icon with nothing else really interesting going on. It's hard to pull out an emotion from something so tiny. The colors, however, are good."
[x] #7 - Positive [No comment]

Congratulations to all three of you! :D and thank you to everyone who participated this round ^_^