American Idol, top 10 guys

[arabian]

Guys instead of the girls tonight. Thoughts behind the cut, but first, I frickin' love Ellen. Period.

Comments

[butterfly]

I agree with you completely on Andrew Garcia. He took a real step back this week.

Tim Urban was so much better this week than last week. I enjoyed his performance.

[eolivet]

And for goodness' sake, Kris won LAST YEAR! Don't sing a song he did, even if it wasn't one of his better-known ones.

Really good point, actually -- I'd forgotten Kris sang that song...

The reason I'm listing John Park last is because I COMPLETELY FORGOT HIM.

Seriously. And I had such high hopes for him...

Lee Dewyze is good, but his voice is just so ... same-y to me

I was just saying to someone else that I really, really want to like this guy -- I do like his voice and I like him (and he's from the town where I lived when I was a little girl ;p ) but it's too...not!David Cook and not!Kris Allen and I just don't know whether I can do another "moderately attractive white guy with a guitar* who changes songs up" for the third straight year. :/

* I know Kris played the piano, too. :p

[beatlegirl59]

I like Tim Urban too! And Andrew was sooo disappointing this week. Bummer.