#01

Apr 25, 2012 11:47


Read more... )

Leave a comment

anonymous April 25 2012, 15:06:19 UTC
which fandoms do you guys find have the best/worst average quality of icons?

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 15:17:01 UTC
i find that a lot of overhyped icons have been made for legend of the seeker, sherlock, and dr who, but there are so many that it's hard not to find some actually really great icons in there too.

generally i find castle and criminal minds icons to be butt ugly.

i wish lesser known shows would get some icon community love, like grimm, raising hope, or white collar. there are actually a lot of good icons, made by some really unknown makers, and i think they all deserve some more attention.

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 15:22:55 UTC
I agree, I would kill to have someone make good quality Criminal Minds icons, I love that show so much!

made by some really unknown makers, and i think they all deserve some more attention.

Oh, I would love to see those, maybe you could post some of them to iconpraise?, Pretty please, I would love to see them!

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 15:34:34 UTC
haha i'd be outing myself pretty fast then! but yeah, i'm actually really interested in this thread so i can go icon-hunting for missed gems in a bunch of different fandoms. i have a good list put together for grimm already, maybe i'll get that up soon.

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 15:38:44 UTC
LOL! But you could mix them in with other icons from different "more well known fandoms", nobody would notice then I think :)

And so many different people are posting there these days too, so I don't think anyone would think twice about it.

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 16:00:41 UTC
I've seen so many pretty icons for Legend of the Seeker, so much so I feel tempted to icon the show without even watching it - mostly because I hear the show is pretty bad. :/

And yes, couldn't agree more regarding Castle and CM icons. I think it's because the original caps are pretty bleak and hard to color. Also, both shows just aren't visually pleasing - I find it hard to be inspired by the caps.

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 16:05:58 UTC
legend of the seeker has really, really amazing videography, and an incredibly attractive cast. i watched it for that alone, and the campiness eventually grew on me.

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 16:15:45 UTC
Yes to the attractive cast part! Oh my god, CARA is hawt! Wanna icon her so badly. ♥

Reply

anonymous April 26 2012, 02:00:55 UTC
THIS. Exactly why I watched it too, and the camp was annoying for about 3 episodes.

Reply

anonymous April 29 2012, 07:11:34 UTC
:'(

I don't find my Criminal Minds icons ugly. :( (okay some yes, but not all. Reid is pretty I can't help myself.)

Also I've made some White Collar icons before. :D Before I got Photoshop though, so they mostly suck. :P

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 15:20:28 UTC
I think procedurals have the worst icons? They're not hugely popular, so most icons come from people who can barely use graphic editors.

The best... probably all the popular British shows, lol. Particularly Sherlock, Doctor Who & Downton Abbey. And maybe Fringe & Lost from the American ones.

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 21:02:01 UTC
I agree. I tried to find some Bones icons and it was not pretty :|

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 15:55:52 UTC
I love Grey's Anatomy but jeez, the caps are super hard to prettify. I rarely ever find good GA icons. :/

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 15:59:01 UTC
The icarly fandom has the worst icons, believe me THE WORST.

Reply

anonymous April 25 2012, 16:49:17 UTC
kpop. always. the worst.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up