Challenge 1-4 : Results
Okay, we're back on track! Lacking HTML for now D:
ELIMINATIONS
Icon 16 with -9 overall points (desibabycakes)
Icon 8 with -7 overall points (oulan)
Icon 11 with -6 overall points (dragon_gypsy)
Icon 4 with -5 overall points (kirikaito)
PEOPLE'S CHOICE
Icon 19 with +5 overall points (ignored_tears)
MOD'S CHOICE
#10 (tobakichan)
I think, this is the first icon that really caught my eye. I like the fact that you used nearly the entire image to icon and gave it antique-ish look by framing it under those rectangles. I also like the little addition of the light blue on the side that doesn't ruin the overall composition. :)
RESULTS TALLY
Icon 1: -2 and +1 for -1 overall points
Icon 2: -3 and +3 for 0 overall points
Icon 3: -0 and +0 for 0 overall points
Icon 4: -5 and +0 for -5 overall points
Icon 5: -0 and +3 for 3 overall points
Icon 6: -3 and +1 for -2 overall points
Icon 7: -0 and +1 for 1 overall points
Icon 8: -7 and +0 for -7 overall points
Icon 9: -1 and +0 for -1 overall points
Icon 10: -1 and +5 for +4 overall points
Icon 11: -6 and +0 for -6 overall points
Icon 12: -1 and +1 for 0 overall points
Icon 13: -4 and +1 for -3 overall points
Icon 14: -5 and +3 for -2 overall points
Icon 15: -0 and +1 for 1 overall points
Icon 16: -9 and +0 for -9 overall points
Icon 17: -2 and +2 for 0 overall points
Icon 18: -1 and +0 for 1 overall points
Icon 19: -0 and +5 for 5 overall points
Icon 20: -4 and +0 for -4 overall points
Icon 21: -1 and + 1 for 0 overall points
Please reply with your icon # if you would like your crits. If you do not get e-mail notifications, please say so and we will leave the comment unscreened.
I don't think I've forgotten or miscounted anything, but please speak up if something seems wrong :) Challenge 5 and the Come Back Challenge will be up in a moment!
ELIMINATIONS
Icon 16 with -9 overall points (desibabycakes)
Icon 8 with -7 overall points (oulan)
Icon 11 with -6 overall points (dragon_gypsy)
Icon 4 with -5 overall points (kirikaito)
PEOPLE'S CHOICE
Icon 19 with +5 overall points (ignored_tears)
MOD'S CHOICE
#10 (tobakichan)
I think, this is the first icon that really caught my eye. I like the fact that you used nearly the entire image to icon and gave it antique-ish look by framing it under those rectangles. I also like the little addition of the light blue on the side that doesn't ruin the overall composition. :)
RESULTS TALLY
Icon 1: -2 and +1 for -1 overall points
Icon 2: -3 and +3 for 0 overall points
Icon 3: -0 and +0 for 0 overall points
Icon 4: -5 and +0 for -5 overall points
Icon 5: -0 and +3 for 3 overall points
Icon 6: -3 and +1 for -2 overall points
Icon 7: -0 and +1 for 1 overall points
Icon 8: -7 and +0 for -7 overall points
Icon 9: -1 and +0 for -1 overall points
Icon 10: -1 and +5 for +4 overall points
Icon 11: -6 and +0 for -6 overall points
Icon 12: -1 and +1 for 0 overall points
Icon 13: -4 and +1 for -3 overall points
Icon 14: -5 and +3 for -2 overall points
Icon 15: -0 and +1 for 1 overall points
Icon 16: -9 and +0 for -9 overall points
Icon 17: -2 and +2 for 0 overall points
Icon 18: -1 and +0 for 1 overall points
Icon 19: -0 and +5 for 5 overall points
Icon 20: -4 and +0 for -4 overall points
Icon 21: -1 and + 1 for 0 overall points
Please reply with your icon # if you would like your crits. If you do not get e-mail notifications, please say so and we will leave the comment unscreened.
I don't think I've forgotten or miscounted anything, but please speak up if something seems wrong :) Challenge 5 and the Come Back Challenge will be up in a moment!