ANIMANGA LIMS ROUND FOUR: CH. 05 RESULTS
Well we finally got a huge slew of votes, so thanks to everyone for advertising! I held out so that things would at least stay on schedule a bit. XD; Hopefully we don't have to do this next time.
Challenge 4-5 ELIMINATIONS (VOTED OFF):
by senbonzakura77 (#15) - -21pts
by scherzando (#13) - -17pts
by kawaii_chicken (#18) - -14pts
by dried_frog_pill (#06) - -12pts
Challenge 4-5 ELIMINATIONS (DIDN'T SUBMIT ON TIME):
fiendie, intimidate, nabreus, nopamuk
Round 04 WITHDRAWALS:
caesyrian
To eliminees: thank you all for having participated in Round 04! Please continue to vote and comment here at animanga_lims, as we truly do appreciate your interest. Stay tuned for our Comeback Challenge, and there is always Round 05!
There are 29 icon-makers left in the running for Round 04. ( OFFICIAL LIST)
Challenge 4-5 PEOPLE'S CHOICE:
by j3tfire (#08) - +8pts
by dragonsquee (#09) - +3pts
by watermist (#14) - +8pts
* Comment to this post if you would like banners.
Challenge 4-5 MODS' CHOICES:
telecast's:
by oxygene (#16)
I really love the color scheme and composition of this icon. I do think that Yuusuke is a little too washed out, but the strengths of this icon make that ignorable. I really like the typography, as well. Great job!
MORE LATER, lalala silverqe isn't really here atm.
Challenge 4-5 RESULTS TALLY:
1. 10 vote-offs, +3 faves = -7 pts
2. 5 vote-offs, +4 faves = -1 pts
3. 3 vote-offs, +2 faves = -1 pt
4. 2 vote-offs, +3 faves = +1 pt
5. 4 vote-offs, +4 faves = 0 pts
6. 12 vote-offs = -12 pts
7. 6 vote-offs = -6 pts
8. 0 vote-offs, +8 faves = +8 pts
9. 0 vote-offs, +8 faves = +8 pts
10. 0 vote-offs, +3 faves = +3 pts
11. 10 vote-offs, +1 fave = -9 pts
12. 3 vote-offs = -3 pts
13. 17 vote-offs = -17 pts
14. 1 vote-offs, +9 faves = +8 pts
15. 21 vote-offs = -21 pts
16. 6 vote-offs = -6 pts
17. 6 vote-offs, +4 faves = -2 pts
18. 18 vote-offs, +4 faves = -14 pts
19. 1 vote-off, +3 faves = +2 pts
20. 7 vote-offs, +7 faves = 0 pts
21. 1 vote-off, +2 faves = +1 pt
Link to voting table here.
If you would like your critiques, please leave a comment with the number of your icon. We will reply with a list of all the good/bad crits you received. ALL REPLIES WILL BE SCREENED, so if you do not get comments e-mailed to you, tell us and we will leave the crits unscreened. Some crits can be a bit harsh, so do not ask for your critiques unless you're sure you can handle it. All crits will be kept 100% anonymous.
Challenge 4-5 ELIMINATIONS (VOTED OFF):
by senbonzakura77 (#15) - -21pts
by scherzando (#13) - -17pts
by kawaii_chicken (#18) - -14pts
by dried_frog_pill (#06) - -12pts
Challenge 4-5 ELIMINATIONS (DIDN'T SUBMIT ON TIME):
fiendie, intimidate, nabreus, nopamuk
Round 04 WITHDRAWALS:
caesyrian
To eliminees: thank you all for having participated in Round 04! Please continue to vote and comment here at animanga_lims, as we truly do appreciate your interest. Stay tuned for our Comeback Challenge, and there is always Round 05!
There are 29 icon-makers left in the running for Round 04. ( OFFICIAL LIST)
Challenge 4-5 PEOPLE'S CHOICE:
by j3tfire (#08) - +8pts
by dragonsquee (#09) - +3pts
by watermist (#14) - +8pts
* Comment to this post if you would like banners.
Challenge 4-5 MODS' CHOICES:
telecast's:
by oxygene (#16)
I really love the color scheme and composition of this icon. I do think that Yuusuke is a little too washed out, but the strengths of this icon make that ignorable. I really like the typography, as well. Great job!
MORE LATER, lalala silverqe isn't really here atm.
Challenge 4-5 RESULTS TALLY:
1. 10 vote-offs, +3 faves = -7 pts
2. 5 vote-offs, +4 faves = -1 pts
3. 3 vote-offs, +2 faves = -1 pt
4. 2 vote-offs, +3 faves = +1 pt
5. 4 vote-offs, +4 faves = 0 pts
6. 12 vote-offs = -12 pts
7. 6 vote-offs = -6 pts
8. 0 vote-offs, +8 faves = +8 pts
9. 0 vote-offs, +8 faves = +8 pts
10. 0 vote-offs, +3 faves = +3 pts
11. 10 vote-offs, +1 fave = -9 pts
12. 3 vote-offs = -3 pts
13. 17 vote-offs = -17 pts
14. 1 vote-offs, +9 faves = +8 pts
15. 21 vote-offs = -21 pts
16. 6 vote-offs = -6 pts
17. 6 vote-offs, +4 faves = -2 pts
18. 18 vote-offs, +4 faves = -14 pts
19. 1 vote-off, +3 faves = +2 pts
20. 7 vote-offs, +7 faves = 0 pts
21. 1 vote-off, +2 faves = +1 pt
Link to voting table here.
If you would like your critiques, please leave a comment with the number of your icon. We will reply with a list of all the good/bad crits you received. ALL REPLIES WILL BE SCREENED, so if you do not get comments e-mailed to you, tell us and we will leave the crits unscreened. Some crits can be a bit harsh, so do not ask for your critiques unless you're sure you can handle it. All crits will be kept 100% anonymous.