Animanga LIMS Round Three: CB2 RESULTS
Here are the results of the Comeback Challenge!
The two people who get to come back are...
(#15) by powercorrupts - 5 votes
* Out of all of these icons, I think this one has the best cropping.
* I really like how you cropped the image and how the image isn't overpowered by text/textures/effects. The colors are really nice as well and I like how the text isn't cheesy.
* Awesome coloring here, the blues look so different from the other Rei icons in the batch. The subtle use of light textures adds some nice depth, and the text is my favorite part of the icon ♥
* This icon is a great example of perfect fusion between text and image.
* Very good crop, imo. (I love the one eye crop the most XD). The colouring is nice, it's more.. dull? not contrasted? kinda? than others but I think it works. There's a good balance. I also like the typography and how the colours match the icon.
(#16) by undini - 5 votes
* Beautiful composition and coloring!
* The colors are clean and pretty, and it enhances the image's overall quality. The cropping and text placement is nice too. The box the text is in looks a little odd though, maybe if it was a little longer on the left side.
* The blue coloring is wonderful. I’m not sure how well-integrated the box is, but the text and everything looks great anyway. Good job!
* The overall composition is nice. Rei takes up most of the icon but it works very well. The coloring is pretty. The text box + text are nice as well~.
* Lovely colouring! The crop is decent, not quite omgamazingsocool but it's still good. XD; I like the typography very much. :3
undini has a skip left, powercorrupts does not.
1. 2 fave votes
2. 0 fave votes
3. 1 fave votes
4. 0 fave votes
5. 3 fave votes
6. 1 fave votes
7. 0 fave votes
8. 4 fave votes
9. 2 fave votes
10. 2 fave votes
11. 4 fave votes
12. 0 fave votes
13. 0 fave votes
14. 0 fave votes
15. 5 fave votes
16. 5 fave votes
17. 0 fave votes
18. 0 fave votes
19. 1 fave votes
20. 0 fave votes
Link to voting table here.
Thanks to everyone who voted and participated! If any of you would like your critiques, please leave a comment with the number of your icon. ALL REPLIES WILL BE SCREENED, so if you do not get comments e-mailed to you, tell us and we will leave the crits unscreened.
The two people who get to come back are...
(#15) by powercorrupts - 5 votes
* Out of all of these icons, I think this one has the best cropping.
* I really like how you cropped the image and how the image isn't overpowered by text/textures/effects. The colors are really nice as well and I like how the text isn't cheesy.
* Awesome coloring here, the blues look so different from the other Rei icons in the batch. The subtle use of light textures adds some nice depth, and the text is my favorite part of the icon ♥
* This icon is a great example of perfect fusion between text and image.
* Very good crop, imo. (I love the one eye crop the most XD). The colouring is nice, it's more.. dull? not contrasted? kinda? than others but I think it works. There's a good balance. I also like the typography and how the colours match the icon.
(#16) by undini - 5 votes
* Beautiful composition and coloring!
* The colors are clean and pretty, and it enhances the image's overall quality. The cropping and text placement is nice too. The box the text is in looks a little odd though, maybe if it was a little longer on the left side.
* The blue coloring is wonderful. I’m not sure how well-integrated the box is, but the text and everything looks great anyway. Good job!
* The overall composition is nice. Rei takes up most of the icon but it works very well. The coloring is pretty. The text box + text are nice as well~.
* Lovely colouring! The crop is decent, not quite omgamazingsocool but it's still good. XD; I like the typography very much. :3
undini has a skip left, powercorrupts does not.
1. 2 fave votes
2. 0 fave votes
3. 1 fave votes
4. 0 fave votes
5. 3 fave votes
6. 1 fave votes
7. 0 fave votes
8. 4 fave votes
9. 2 fave votes
10. 2 fave votes
11. 4 fave votes
12. 0 fave votes
13. 0 fave votes
14. 0 fave votes
15. 5 fave votes
16. 5 fave votes
17. 0 fave votes
18. 0 fave votes
19. 1 fave votes
20. 0 fave votes
Link to voting table here.
Thanks to everyone who voted and participated! If any of you would like your critiques, please leave a comment with the number of your icon. ALL REPLIES WILL BE SCREENED, so if you do not get comments e-mailed to you, tell us and we will leave the crits unscreened.