Voting: Round 2 ; Challenge 2
VOTING ; RD. 02 - Challenge 02
UGH REWRITING CODES SUCKS. Alright after an extension we got 27/35 entries! Which is great. I'm glad you guys pulled through. I'm sorry for making this a hard theme. I promise nest week will be fun. &hearts and maybe easy.
Skipping: ms_poptart, strawberries_85, coloredpastels
Eliminated/Defaults: skyships, whitelilies22, hamimifk, margyydoodle
Withdrawals: dashberlin
① Quick comment: Since we had 4 defaults, 3 skips, & 1 withdrawal there will be no eliminations this week. I thought it'd be extremely unfair considering that you guys took time out to submit. I appreciate that.
② When you vote, vote based on how well constructed it is & how it looks. Do not base your voting on the fact that you think the icon looks dated, ugly, etc. Also everyone was allowed to interpret & modernize the theme the way they saw fit. Alright? Alright.
③ I wound up major failing this round & forgot to check out some of the sources for the images or where the images were from. Since I just noticed this I'm letting it through this week. After that, no mas.
④ If there are any mistakes tell me. I had to redo the fucking code all over again because livejournal decided to eat the code/page & not autosave. :/ Still raging.
Voting Form:
Main Theme: Doing It Right
#00 F - crit
#00 F - crit
#00 F - crit
#00 F - crit
#00 F - crit
#00 F - crit
Bonus Theme: Doing It Wrong
#00 U - crit
#00 U - crit
#00 U - crit
#00 U - crit
#00 U - crit
#00 U - crit
Additional Comments:
#00 O - crit (add as many as you want)
Click the number above to see the original scan & hover over the icon to see the series. I would really recommend doing this so you can see how awesome the change is.
Rules:
· No voting for yourself in general, that also goes for getting others to vote for you.
· Anyone can vote. Participants MUST vote please, if you had time to make an icon you have time to vote. Plus it will make the results be more balanced.
· Comments for favorite icons are optional, though highly recommended.
· Vote for 6 icons from the "Doing it right" section for People's Choice & 6 from the "Doing it wrong" section. Vote based on quality of the icon (textures, quality, coloring), not because you like the character, js.
· Be constructive & positive. chacusha made a great voting guideline for wd_lims on how to vote, so have a read at it. :D
· Also if it's in the voting post, I accepted it, so in b4 it doesn't fit the theme, js.
· Challenge here for reference purposes.
· Also if it's in here, I accepted it, so in b4 it doesn't fit the theme, js.
Main Theme: Doing It Right
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Bonus Theme: Doing It Wrong
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
Comments are screened & voting will end late Monday night, February 21st or so. So get voting plz.
ALSSSOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
SIGN UP IF YOU HAVEN'T DONE SO. :D
UGH REWRITING CODES SUCKS. Alright after an extension we got 27/35 entries! Which is great. I'm glad you guys pulled through. I'm sorry for making this a hard theme. I promise nest week will be fun. &hearts and maybe easy.
Skipping: ms_poptart, strawberries_85, coloredpastels
Eliminated/Defaults: skyships, whitelilies22, hamimifk, margyydoodle
Withdrawals: dashberlin
① Quick comment: Since we had 4 defaults, 3 skips, & 1 withdrawal there will be no eliminations this week. I thought it'd be extremely unfair considering that you guys took time out to submit. I appreciate that.
② When you vote, vote based on how well constructed it is & how it looks. Do not base your voting on the fact that you think the icon looks dated, ugly, etc. Also everyone was allowed to interpret & modernize the theme the way they saw fit. Alright? Alright.
③ I wound up major failing this round & forgot to check out some of the sources for the images or where the images were from. Since I just noticed this I'm letting it through this week. After that, no mas.
④ If there are any mistakes tell me. I had to redo the fucking code all over again because livejournal decided to eat the code/page & not autosave. :/ Still raging.
Voting Form:
Main Theme: Doing It Right
#00 F - crit
#00 F - crit
#00 F - crit
#00 F - crit
#00 F - crit
#00 F - crit
Bonus Theme: Doing It Wrong
#00 U - crit
#00 U - crit
#00 U - crit
#00 U - crit
#00 U - crit
#00 U - crit
Additional Comments:
#00 O - crit (add as many as you want)
Click the number above to see the original scan & hover over the icon to see the series. I would really recommend doing this so you can see how awesome the change is.
Rules:
· No voting for yourself in general, that also goes for getting others to vote for you.
· Anyone can vote. Participants MUST vote please, if you had time to make an icon you have time to vote. Plus it will make the results be more balanced.
· Comments for favorite icons are optional, though highly recommended.
· Vote for 6 icons from the "Doing it right" section for People's Choice & 6 from the "Doing it wrong" section. Vote based on quality of the icon (textures, quality, coloring), not because you like the character, js.
· Be constructive & positive. chacusha made a great voting guideline for wd_lims on how to vote, so have a read at it. :D
· Also if it's in the voting post, I accepted it, so in b4 it doesn't fit the theme, js.
· Challenge here for reference purposes.
· Also if it's in here, I accepted it, so in b4 it doesn't fit the theme, js.
Main Theme: Doing It Right
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Bonus Theme: Doing It Wrong
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
Comments are screened & voting will end late Monday night, February 21st or so. So get voting plz.
ALSSSOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
SIGN UP IF YOU HAVEN'T DONE SO. :D