Leave a comment

kalimac January 8 2016, 12:25:00 UTC
The angry Star Wars guy is angry at the other article calling Finn a janitor. He says, "Finn was a Stormtrooper assigned to sanitation .... Nowhere in this movie is it said that Finn was a janitor." Um ... you just did.

Reply

erindubitably January 8 2016, 12:57:42 UTC
I think maybe it's the difference between 'Stormtrooper who does sanitation duties while not in combat' and 'janitor' that got him riled up. I mean, plenty of soldiers do sanitation stuff when they're not fighting, I'd imagine, but we don't call them janitors.

Reply

cartesiandaemon January 8 2016, 13:56:36 UTC
That makes sense. It probably could have been clearer in the film, I got that sense that Finn had had combat training but no experience, but I wasn't completely sure.

Reply

movingfinger January 8 2016, 18:58:53 UTC
That was my sense, too, that we see him in his first real combat and he realizes it's not for him. Which suggests that this culture doesn't have simulators, or not very good ones.

On Finn's "sanitation" work, I didn't think he was a janitor either: the complex has been under construction for years, and I took "sanitation" to mean he was in the plumbing crew---and that was why he knew so much detail about the layout and functions of the various areas, because plumbers have to know everything or you'll get a waste pipe routed through your hyper-plasma-planet laser area.

I'm not clear on what was supposed to happen when they used up either a star or a planet with that weapon. (Possibly the characters weren't either.) The scenes with the First Order's big opening day concert looked distractingly like scenes from Captain America and I may have missed something, thinking about the film homages etc going on there.

Reply

steer January 8 2016, 13:27:40 UTC
Surely in this world most recruits get assigned the equivalent of latrine duty at some point in their careers but you wouldn't call any of them janitors.

Reply

octopoid_horror January 8 2016, 17:26:45 UTC
Han doesn't seem the type to have underwent military service...

Reply

drplokta January 8 2016, 19:15:17 UTC
If you take a look at the only waste disposal facility we've actually seen in Star Wars, in Episode IV, it becomes apparent that sanitation is an elite duty given to only the best trained, best equipped and most experienced soldiers -- because they're the only ones who have a chance of survival.

Reply

steer January 10 2016, 20:44:39 UTC
Hah... yes, that is a fair point. You would assign someone to clean that up only if you knew they were the toughest.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up