Leave a comment

cmcmck January 19 2015, 11:27:19 UTC
As ever, the transgender piece assumes we all transition late. Some people may have these experiences, not all do.

I was fifteen, so my experience of what we laughingly call 'the world of work' is much the same as any other woman's (with the same long term desire to kick the patriarchy in a rather tender portion of its collective anatomy)!

Reply

apostle_of_eris January 19 2015, 11:57:34 UTC
I read it as considering people who transitioned in mid life as having experience from both situations. If someone transitioned earlier, they wouldn't have the experiences to compare.

Reply

cmcmck January 19 2015, 12:06:20 UTC
True, but the assumption that a majority of trans people transition late is one of those 'what everybody knows' tropes and it happens to be wrong and its becoming wronger (if that's a word :o) as attitudes toward treatment change for the better.

They should maybe have said 'some transgender people' rather than 'transgender people'.

Reply

andrewducker January 19 2015, 12:14:06 UTC
This is a common theme - and something that people argue back and forth about a lot.

Hence, for instance, #NotAllMen.

Reply

cmcmck January 19 2015, 12:33:44 UTC
I was once moved to write a fairly lengthy piece deconstructing 'what everybody knows' about trans people.

It's something of a bete noire for obvious reasons! :o)

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

cmcmck January 20 2015, 07:48:15 UTC
Just so!

This article really doesn't address the complexities involved at all.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up