Leave a comment

bart_calendar September 9 2013, 12:17:45 UTC
Of course. Attwood has managed to write incredibly well received science fiction while still being overtly female.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/08/books/review/maddaddam-by-margaret-atwood.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0

Reply

xenophanean September 9 2013, 12:42:11 UTC
She famously denies being a science fiction writer, which has the perverse effect of making the science fiction community furiously declare that she *is* one.

To be fair, one of the lead proponents of this, is her big fan, Ursula Le Guin (also an excellent sci-fi writer).

Reply

bart_calendar September 9 2013, 12:44:26 UTC
She certainly is a sci-fi writer despite her protesting that fact.

Reply

xenophanean September 9 2013, 12:52:30 UTC
Indeed so, however the dogged insistence, from a community where other female writers have such trouble being recognized is an amusing irony. Which is possibly why she still does it.

Reply

chess September 9 2013, 12:47:47 UTC
Mostly because she got famous writing The Handmaid's Tale which was a gender issues book, and women are allowed to write SF if it's romance or gender issues, though?

Reply

philmophlegm September 9 2013, 13:03:35 UTC
I think that's a good point. Also, since lots of the more prominent female SF authors do write SF with a "gender issues" bent, your more sexist 'traditional' male SF reader may assume that when he sees a new SF paperback from a female writer in his local bookstore, that it's going to be an avant-garde exploration of far-future gender issues and a searing indictment of the contemporary patriarchy, or whatever. If all he wants is some military space opera where cool guys shoot aliens and get the girl, he'll move along the shelf.

Reply

andrewducker September 9 2013, 13:04:37 UTC
Which would be a shame, considering Lois McMaster Bujold!

Reply

philmophlegm September 9 2013, 13:12:08 UTC
Quite.

(Userpic selected in honour of Tanith Lee, who while generally regarded more as a fantasy author, has written SF, including two episodes of Blake's 7.)

Reply

strawberryfrog September 9 2013, 20:59:43 UTC
Probably. Though Oryx and Crake and the two sequels aren't (mainly) about gender issues. They are definitely Science fiction to me, albeit not SF written by someone very familiar with its cannon of end-of-the-world stories.

Reply

woodpijn September 10 2013, 14:34:03 UTC
I haven't read those, but that's about what I thought of Handmaid's Tale: SF written by someone who hasn't read any SF.

Reply

strawberryfrog September 10 2013, 18:44:04 UTC
it's quite well articulated here. Though IMHO Atwood's books are still very much worth a read.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up