Leave a comment

On Guns in the US - or the UK equilvalent. danieldwilliam August 14 2013, 12:22:35 UTC
I find the way USians view guns difficult to understand. The trade of theoretical liberty against actual deaths doesn’t seem like a good deal to me. I wonder every time I see a statistic about gun deaths in the US why they seem to have the balance between gun ownership and not being shot so out.

I think my question for myself today is - what is it about our own culture in the UK that looks really, really dumb to other cultures but which we are just unable to see?

Reply

simont August 14 2013, 13:43:17 UTC
The trade of theoretical liberty against actual deaths doesn’t seem like a good deal to me.

I idly wonder if Franklin's principle has conditioned a large number of Americans against even trying to assess any question quantitatively based on results, as soon as they realise it can be framed as liberty vs safety.

(Granted, Franklin's actual statement contained some weasel words which more or less boil down to 'well yes but don't go way over the top when applying this', but those tend to get forgotten when it's requoted...)

Reply

danieldwilliam August 14 2013, 13:50:49 UTC
That might well be it.

It’s a very quotable quote.

Reply

Re: On Guns in the US - or the UK equilvalent. naath August 14 2013, 15:13:28 UTC
Americans often seem baffled by the NHS...

Reply

Re: On Guns in the US - or the UK equilvalent. cartesiandaemon August 14 2013, 15:38:18 UTC
True, but this time we're right :)

Reply

Re: On Guns in the US - or the UK equilvalent. danieldwilliam August 15 2013, 08:49:01 UTC
Yeah, but that feels somewhat different to me. Perhaps it’s because I’m British and therefore mentally inside NHS space but I don’t see the two as quite on a par ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up