Cycle 3 Round 4 RESULTS

[brookeh777]

The results were decided by a handful of votes. ! We could always use more voters. I'm not sure why my color-coded comments aren't showing up. They show up in the preview. Hmm.

Elimination  :


by
isaymeow with 3 negative votes.

People's Choice  :


by 
trytryagain with 1 positive vote.

Mod's Choice :


by
sick_forever

I absolutely adore the textures used in this icon! Quite creative! May I use this icon as the community's icon? =)

Voting Tally  :

1. -3
2. --
3. +2 - 1 = +1

Comments :

[1] - The text is difficult to read and the scratchy texture is a little much.
    -The cracks or spiderwebs or whatever are interesting but do not work well with this icon, the coloring isn't that interesting, the text is a bit hard to read.
    -The text looks neat, but something between the texture and the coloring makes Amy's face looks swollen/chubby.

[2] {none!}

[3] -This is hard, but I'm going to say #3 because while the coloring and the watercolor background is amazing, the text placement or maybe the text itself just doesn't fit.
   - The texture and text are both gorgeous.
    -This icon is amazing, I love the coloring and the text. Great job.