So in the Cain Nightlord post we all decided that smirking Cain with darker hair looked a bit like Gerald. prettyarbitrary made his eyes silver and darkened his hair, but also his skin, which doesn't go well with his undead nature. So I played a bit with the images and, lo and behold, the "new and improved" Gerald look-alike!
Edit: I'm making this a public post for various reasons.
Images from what was to be the Coldfire manga but is now gone and I have no idea if it will ever come back: