Solomin's gazes to camera? - Western eye on the Livanov series/ Странный взгляд Виталия Соломина?

Oct 21, 2007 18:17

A few days ago, an English person and the blogger-Sherlockian DrSative wrote the interesting review of the Livanov series. You may read it on the forum ezboard.com and my detailed answer is here too. However, I have decided to post DrSative's text in my LJ in English and Russian. Particuarly, I'd like the readeres will take notice on the point ( Read more... )

solomin, russian sherlock holmes, западные рецензии на русского Холмса, movie, livanov, holmes, discussion, sherlock holmes, review

Leave a comment

alek_morse October 21 2007, 23:57:55 UTC
///...he doesn't note that any of the other actors have the same trait. ///

I agree. It's strangely a bit.
But I guess DrSative meant almost imperceptible something in Solomin's performance. Honestly, I too don't know describe some touches of Vitaly Solomin's play. In every film, Solomin plays own roles with some "hidden meaning", "doubble bottom", I think. My be, did DrSative mean that it? That's why I asked DrSative to clarify this...

///In contrast, I had no problem with the depiction of Lestrade, and I'm not sure how the 4 inches in height factors into things.///

As I wrote before, the Scotland Yard had the official instruction to employ "small" men for Detective. I think Doyle knew this. Perhaps, in 1880s, this requirement have transformed into open secret and the stereotype of police officer.

On whole, I have to say I like the DrSative's review. And I like DrSative's way: he has decided to contrast western view with the play of Russian actors. May be, it's some provocative, but very creative too.

P.S. I hope shall you not object if I translate our discussion into Russian? A little later on...

Reply


Leave a comment

Up