The Quibbler- Deathly Hallows SPOILER quibbles

Jul 28, 2007 20:45

A few quibbles (page numbers are from the American edition)

p. 271- yes, Harry and his buds are secret keepers of 12 Grimauld Place, but so is Snape, the sleeping snake. Of course, Snape has no desire to share the OotP's 20 with the Death Eaters, but the OotP doesn't know that.

p. 363- either time is moving backward or the night lasted all the next day

p 482-- If Mr. Weasley is the secret-keeper for Aunt Muriel's place, then why is Bill able to casually inform our heroes that that's where the Weasley family is hidden?

p 535- How come Hermione's shield spell is able to go under the enchanted waterfall unharmed?

p. 690-- Perhaps portrait-Dumbledore is just being modest, but George's ear isn't the only reason Snape shouldn't expect a warm greeting from the OotP--

p. 721-- How does Dumbly know what happened after his last chat with Snape?
(Possible answers:
*Snape turned into a portrait and had a chat with Dumbly's portrait
*Snape just saw him passing through, passing through)
Previous post
Up