R1 Challenge 003 Results

[pixelwater]

Thank you for the votes and onto the results! Sorry for not posting this up yesterday, got busy doing a project.



Eliminated:

netbug009
with -8 votes



Thank you for participating! I hope you'll stick around and participate in the comeback challenge! :D

People's Choice: / Mod's Choice:

MusoGato
with +6 votes

icedragoncat
with +4 votes





+ Mod's choice: Wow, I really loved this icon! The creativity, the great text placement, it was amazing!

To the Elimanted/People's Choice/Mod's Choice: please state if you want a banner or not.

Tally:
#001: -- *
#002: --
#003: -7
#004: -8
#005: -4
#006: +6
#007: +4
#008: -1
#009: -1/+1=0 *
#010: -4/+1=-3
* means you received a general comment. :D

If you want your critiques please state your icon #, comments will be screened.
Voting table is here.

IceDragonCat is your banner maker (if you want another banner maker to make your award, let me know and I'll make it).
silentevocation has the next challenge.