Let's talk 'Six of One'
'Six of One' seems to be a very polarizing episode for A/R fans, particularly the 'Admiral Atheist' scene. I know of more than one fan who could no longer ship the pairing after this very scene.
Firstly, a slightly tongue in cheek recap of the episode:
Was Adama too cutting? Was Roslin? Did the scene change how you felt about one or both of the characters?
I find it interesting to contrast this scene with the one at the end of 'Faith' (the 'you made me believe' scene). Why is Adama far more able to talk about loss in the 'Faith' scene than in this one?
Do you agree with Eric Goldman of IGN.com (from his review of 'Six of One'):
Beyond the excellent performances, this scene worked so well because Adama and Roslin have built up so much trust (and perhaps more?) that it's very difficult and effective to see them at odds in such a serious way.
Firstly, a slightly tongue in cheek recap of the episode:
Click to viewWas Adama too cutting? Was Roslin? Did the scene change how you felt about one or both of the characters?
I find it interesting to contrast this scene with the one at the end of 'Faith' (the 'you made me believe' scene). Why is Adama far more able to talk about loss in the 'Faith' scene than in this one?
Do you agree with Eric Goldman of IGN.com (from his review of 'Six of One'):
Beyond the excellent performances, this scene worked so well because Adama and Roslin have built up so much trust (and perhaps more?) that it's very difficult and effective to see them at odds in such a serious way.