Review: "Heads or Tails," the Two-Face segment from Walt Simonson's "The Judas Coin" (2012)

Jan 12, 2013 04:25

Four months have passed since the release of Walt Simonson's excellent new graphic novel, The Judas Coin, so I think it's finally time for me to examine the story's Two-Face segment, Heads or Tails, in full, exhaustive, spoilery, scan-heavy detail.


Read more... )

new comic reviews, walt simonson

Leave a comment

about_faces January 12 2013, 22:37:06 UTC
I wasn't a huge fan of the rest of the Judas Coin...

Aw.

... but this was the best Two-Face story I've read in years.

Hooray!

... so it very well might have been just you.

Aw.

However, I like your take much better.

Hooray!

Judas Coin is the first I ever heard of Simonson...

Egad! His Thor run is worth checking out, as I understand it's one of the most celebrated runs in all of Marvel's history. I still need to read the whole thing, if I can ever get my hands on 'em. I'd love the get the massive, recolored (coloring was often such shit back then) hardcover omnibus, but sadly, I don't have $150 to throw around.

... but it has me wishing he'd write a Batman comic...

Oh, you and me both! The closest he's ever come to doing a full Batman comic is with his serialized Manhunter story, which ran as back-ups in Detective Comics during the 70's and featured Batman as co-star. It was a very popular story in its day, although I must confess, I don't remember much about it. I have no idea how it holds up. I thought I heard that it was going to be reprinted for the first time in a decade, but I can't find any info anywhere. Aha, found it! It will be reprinted in a collection of writer/editor Archie Goodwin's Batman work! I wonder if it will include the bonus story that Simonson did in the last volume as a tribute to the late Goodwin that wraps up the loose ends from the Manhunter saga? I hope so, but it doesn't seem like it's listed.

Simonson also did the Orion solo series from the late 90's, which was the only time that the New Gods (as done by someone other than Jack Kirby) have ever been interesting to me. Well, that and DeMatteis' Mister Miracle run, but that's something else entirely.

Oh, and one more neat work by Simonson that you can read in its entirety: his adaptation of Alien, which ran in the pages of Heavy Metal. It's recently been rereleased as a massive artist's edition that's also very worth checking out. It really is much, much better than the average comics adaptation of a movie.

Reply

psychopathicus January 13 2013, 02:19:30 UTC
Personally, while I haven't read his whole Thor run either, I've been collecting 'em in TPB. I have three now - 'Thor Visionaries: Walter Simonson', then 'Walter Simonson: Thor Legends' numbers two and three, which follow directly on its heels. None of them have set me back more than fifteen bucks or so, so if you're willing to read it in TPB-length chucks...
I'd say it holds up pretty darn well, myself. I have it collected in 'Manhunter: The Special Edition', with a shiny gold cover and the bonus story included. I got it years ago, back in the late '90's or so, so it's probably out of print, but I wouldn't be surprised if it was knocking around Amazon somewhere.

Reply

about_faces January 13 2013, 07:14:38 UTC
I have the first TPB, and the coloring really hurts my eyes. It's so aggressively dotty and garish. While I had souped-up modernized coloring of old comics (Neal Adams' "improvements" are particularly abhorrent), I do love seeing classic coloring remastered in a restrained, cleaned-up way. The coloring jobs on the original Greatest Batman Stories Ever Told volumes come to mind as the best examples, and from what I've seen of the Thor recoloring in the omnibus, it looks gorgeous too.

Still, I would check out the other Thor volumes, but cash is much tighter than ever. My days of willy-nilly picking up comics that interest me are over for the time being. It's either my local library system (which has a decent selection, but sadly, no Simonson), or whatever else I can find online.

Reply

psychopathicus January 13 2013, 07:25:22 UTC
Well, dude, you don't have to convince me; I have a perpetually echoing hole in place of a bank account. I know exactly where you're coming from. Still, there is always Amazon to consider; I've seen things go used there for as little as one penny plus shipping.
Also, if your library does have a decent selection, they probably have someone behind the scenes who at least knows a little bit about comics, so you might try putting in an order for them. (I specify this detail because if that wasn't the case, It wouldn't be worth it; I called up my local library once to ask if they had some graphic novel or other, and I had to spend a good five minutes explaining to someone what a graphic novel was before he said 'hang on, I'll check'. Needless to say, they didn't have it.)

Reply

deadwalrus January 13 2013, 05:31:49 UTC
Those initial reactions seem oddly familiar...




Oh.

Reply

about_faces January 13 2013, 07:10:40 UTC
The fact that the photo isn't showing up just makes this extra Zoidbergian.

And yeah, I had wanted to find appropriate Zoidberg screenshots, but ehhhh, too much effort.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up